So I spend 4+ hours on Sunday making 3 dozen traditional Runzas (a German/Nebraskan sandwich) for LOs birthday party which is Saturday. Went down to the deep freeze, the door was open everything is ruined and has to be tossed out. (my luck for sure.) So I'm going to plan B, which I need your help on. Her birthday is over dinner, a 5 pm party for 24 people (8 kids, 16 adults.)

Which is the better option:
Sandwich tray and up the amount of sides
Taco Bar/Nacho Bar with all the fixings

Or if you have a similar priced option throw it at me, I have little time and after throwing all that money in the trash I want it to be light on the wallet. (Pizza is not an option since it's a home football game in our city and it takes 3+ hours to get ordered.)

Edit: no dietary restrictions for anyone attending party and are all meat eaters