I bought these two items and trying to decide which one to gift a one year old girl. Here's a link to the elephant so you can see it's features.
http://www.fisher-price.com/en_US/brands/babytoys/products/3-in-1-Bounce-Stride-and-Ride-Elephant
-
I vote for piano - only because we received a number of ride-on/walker toys for J's first birthday and he really only used one.
-
I voted for ride-on because my lo LOOOOOVED (still loves) ride-on toys. L.O.V.E.
-
I voted piano, because I love the quality and look of Melissa and Doug toys. Plus, it's a toy that could be used longer and grow with the child/
-
The piano!
-
DS was obsessed with anything he could push or ride on so I voted for elephant
-
The piano, we also received several different ride/push toys!
-
Is it for your kid or someone else's? If yours go piano. If someone else's, ride on (less obnoxious noise!)
-
I think the elephant will get more play, however the piano is usually thought of as a nicer gift and will outlast the elephant.
I voted elephant (I'd save the piano for a later date).
-
We just got the piano and it's sooo small. I didn't read the dimensions I guess. Lol. I can't imagine a 3 year old using it. LO is 9 months and seems to like it though. I'd still chose the piano.
-
Think it depends on what the kid already has. DD loves her walker but we wouldn't want more than one.
-
Piano!
-
My one year old wouldn't know what to do with the piano. I vote elephant.
-
Piano!!!
-
I voted piano because we have received 2 walkers and 2 ride on as gifts. I think they are pretty common first birthday gifts.
-
The elephant! My sister got my LO a similar ride-on toy for her first birthday and she loved it and still likes to play with it to this day!
-
My son has the elephant and loves using it to practice walking but is too short to use it as a ride on. lol. the piano looks really nice too
-
The piano, but that's only because my LO hates ride on toys! Most other toddlers seem to love them though.
-
I think it depends on the kid. My son is 16 months and would probably like the piano better. He doesn't really care about his ride on toys.
-
Piano. My boys love music and don't really care about ride on toys.
Reply
Subscribe to our newsletter
- Google Plus
- Stumbleupon
- Twitter
- Facebook
- Pinterest
- Favorite0
19 comments