Hellobee Boards

Login/Register

Should the UK leave the European Union?

  1. looch

    wonderful pear / 26210 posts

    @erinbaderin: Question for you, what happens if a non citizen gives birth in Canada? Is that child a citizen as in the US?

  2. sunny

    coconut / 8430 posts

    @looch: yes, that child is Canadian.

  3. looch

    wonderful pear / 26210 posts

    @sunny: thanks! I wasn't sure.

  4. erinbaderin

    pomelo / 5573 posts

    @sunny: Oh, I know, I just see people say it all the time (not here) like you'd say you were moving to a different city.

  5. travelgirl1

    cantaloupe / 6630 posts

    @erinbaderin: @sunny: after having to leave Canada and move back to the UK six months ago, I can assure you Canadian immigration policy is pretty strict. I agree with what you said @sunny: about Canada welcoming immigrants, but they certainly make it hard.

  6. travelgirl1

    cantaloupe / 6630 posts

    @looch: my two kids are Canadian because they were born there. We weren't citizens.

  7. looch

    wonderful pear / 26210 posts

    @travelgirl1: I bring it up because in some countries, it doesn't work this way. If you are born in Switzerland, for example, you as a child inherit your parent's citizenship. You are only a Swiss citizen if you have at least one Swiss citizen parent.

  8. sunny

    coconut / 8430 posts

    @travelgirl1:

  9. Maysprout

    grapefruit / 4800 posts

    @sunny: Canada is pretty strict though. I've had a couple friends on US student visas who couldn't even visit, maybe they could have eventually but it would have been more effort for approval than they were willing to make. One of my sisters last boyfriends they broke up after visiting and he was deported from Canada. It was partly that his US visa was set to expire soon but Canada was like yeah you can't stay here even for a day and figure it out, they had him detained and on a plane out within a couple hours.
    Canada's current policy (though they keep saying they're going to relax it) restricting Mexican visitors is like Trumps wet dream.

  10. Anagram

    eggplant / 11716 posts

    @erinbaderin: my husband already has started the immigration process, but we never "landed". We're in Canada now as I type, actually.....yes, I am (mildly) familiar with immigration policies. My husbands entire extended family (his parents, his sister and her family, his uncles and cousins, second cousins, even his grandmother before she passed) live in Canada. His parents just immigrated a year ago after they retired in the US.

  11. Freckles

    honeydew / 7444 posts

    I thought it was pretty interesting to see the demographics of who voted to stay/leave.

    https://scontent-sea1-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/13438877_10100841155974685_124762478811840847_n.jpg?oh=a020fee61a8992e961d5a1c84e7942ed&oe=580B8928

    What a shit show this is turning into.

  12. lamariniere

    pineapple / 12566 posts

    @looch: No European country gives citizenship automatically based on place of birth. Of course, you can become naturalized at some point, but it's not automatic. My DD was born here and can't claim citizenship based on place of birth. Here, until somewhat recently (20-30 years ago?) you could only become Austrian if your father was.

  13. lamariniere

    pineapple / 12566 posts

    @Freckles: that graphic is crazy.

  14. looch

    wonderful pear / 26210 posts

    @lamariniere: Oh, I didn't realize that it was a widespread thing in Europe. I think even the process to be naturalized is quite complicated.

    Jus Sanguinis vs. Jus Soli. I learned something today, now I can go home!

  15. sunny

    coconut / 8430 posts

    @Maysprout: If they were on US student visas then they might have needed a visa to visit Canada. Every country has set rules on which nationalities require visas for entry (eg. I know Indian passport holders require a visa to enter Canada).

  16. sunny

    coconut / 8430 posts

    @looch: I was just going to point you to the wiki articles on jus soli and jus sanguinis which I found interesting!

  17. lamariniere

    pineapple / 12566 posts

    @looch: I didn't realize it was all of Europe until I looked it up today. I'm actually going through the naturalization process right now and it's quite complicated, long and there are a lot of hoops to jump through.

  18. looch

    wonderful pear / 26210 posts

    @lamariniere: would you believe i was 6 months short of the residency requirement for naturalization when we relocated? If we move back I have to start again! At that point, hopefully, I'll give up my American citizenship as well.

    @sunny: Thanks! I think it brings up an interesting point of discussion (obviously not the intial point of this thread) about the ability for people to move freely about the world. I listened to a very compelling podcast this winter about the ramifications of these man made boundaries. We're really not so free to move around as we should be, I think!

  19. lamariniere

    pineapple / 12566 posts

    @looch: would you give up the US one? I don't have to, I can be dual, but I would possibly consider it for tax purposes.

  20. sunny

    coconut / 8430 posts

    @looch: In my opinion, I think the laws need to catch up with the modern world. People are moving across borders and disenfranchising long time residents (especially in perpetuity) seems like it is recipe for racism and discrimination.

  21. Maysprout

    grapefruit / 4800 posts

    @sunny: yeah they needed tourist visas, which they applied for. One got it eventually but the trip had already happened, the other was rejected, prob bc she just graduated but didn't have a job lined up yet. Just saying they are pretty strict about their policies to make sure immigrants take a legal path.
    @lamariniere: crazy. My kids have citizenship cause of DH to an EU country but they've never lived there. Do some people just end up with citizenship to no country then?

  22. looch

    wonderful pear / 26210 posts

    @lamariniere: yep, just because I do not want to be subject to filing US taxes on world wide income.

    @sunny: agreed.

    It seems the US is a combination of both options though, because my son was born abroad and he's an AMCIT. If the US were jus soli only, he'd not be eligible...am I understanding that correctly?

  23. lamariniere

    pineapple / 12566 posts

    @Maysprout: France, right? They give it through jus sanguinis. Both of my kids are French and my youngest has never lived their. I'm actually not sure what happens to, let's say, refugees who give birth here. My guess is that they still take on their parents' home country citizenship until they fulfil requirements for naturalization. Or there may be exceptions for extreme cases, but I really don't know.

  24. lamariniere

    pineapple / 12566 posts

    @looch: yeah, that part is no fun.

  25. Charm54

    cantaloupe / 6885 posts

    http://cbiftrumpwins.com

    Offer also extends to our UK friends

    In all seriousness though, I hope the UK gets some answers and stability soon. What a terribly uncertain time this must be

  26. littlebug

    honeydew / 7504 posts

    @Freckles: Wow. That is crazy.

  27. lamariniere

    pineapple / 12566 posts

    I thought this was lighthearted, considering the seriousness of it all.



  28. imbali

    apricot / 347 posts

    @Cherrybee: I can't believe we live here. DH and I are about to exchange on a house and today has me thinking that's maaaaaybe a bad idea

  29. Cherrybee

    papaya / 10570 posts

    @imbali: I'm so sorry. I think as long as you are not overcommitting yourselves financially (could afford mortgage if interest rates rise) you should be ok.

    @lamariniere: That's funny!

    Feeling a bit better now. It is what it is...... and I've drunk some wine. We've just got to move forward now and try to be positive, especially since I'm not allowed to move to Canada @erinbaderin: (!) and that's the only place that's not crap right now!

  30. jetsa

    grapefruit / 4663 posts

    @Charm54: I found this probably way too funny I was discussing the info with my husband and he's like silly it's Nova Scotia I was just there. I totally did not put 2 and 2 together at first lol

  31. erinbaderin

    pomelo / 5573 posts

    @Cherrybee: You might be allowed! I'm not opposed to it! I'm just saying the process might take the same two years that the leaving is set to take.

  32. Grace

    cantaloupe / 6730 posts

    @Cherrybee: Has you heard anyone suggesting that the government ignore the referendum? When we had the Quebec referendum in the 90s, they had decided that unless it was a "clear majority", the Canadian govt was not going to honour a vote in Quebec to separate. As it happened, the no vote won, so it never made it that far.

  33. Cherrybee

    papaya / 10570 posts

    @Grace: Lots of people are suggesting it, but its not going to happen - at least, I hope not, because you cant ask the people and then ignore their direction, surely!!?

  34. imbali

    apricot / 347 posts

    @Cherrybee: haha I'm an EU immigrant, so unfortunately more considerations than just affordability
    @Grace: I really think they should have done that - said unless it's a 60% plus majority or something. They are relying on people to make the decision who generally don't know and understand the true facts imo

  35. Cherrybee

    papaya / 10570 posts

    @imbali: Ahh! I see! (why do I think you're from South Africa??). At this point, we have no idea what will happen to EU immigrants who are already here. I hope you will be granted leave to remain.

    Agreed that people were asked to vote on something they didn't understand. My Facebook is full of statuses from disgruntled leave voters who object to being labelled racist or thick...... but the truth is that we had all been told the ramifications of leaving. The arguments for leave were largely just meaningless rhetoric - "taking back control", "making Britain great again". The only issue that made sense was immigration. We were told that the net result of immigration is positive, but people still had concerns . The public had to decide if the issues around immigration were worth destroying our economy for, and plunging us into another recession. Surely the answer is a straight no?? And yet half of general public think they are. That leads me to one of two conclusions about those people:

    - They didn't really understand the issues
    OR
    - They hate immigrants more than they care about anything else, even the financial stability of our country

    Like..... we all knew that leaving would cost our country thousands of jobs, as businesses moved operations out of the UK. But the thought of immigrants "taking our jobs" is more scary??

  36. BSB

    hostess / wonderful apple seed / 16729 posts

    @travelgirl1: So the PM stepped down, I heard late yesterday (sorry I missed it) that he was conservative and was pushing for Brexit. So he got what he wanted but now is resigning? I don't get it.
    Previously, I assumed he was resigning because he didn't agree with the decision.

    ETA: never mind. I see the PM did not support Brexit.

    “I was absolutely clear about my belief that Britain is stronger, safer and better off inside the EU. I made clear the referendum was about this, and this alone, not the future of any single politician, including myself.

    “But the British people made a different decision to take a different path. As such I think the country requires fresh leadership to take it in this direction,” Cameron said.

  37. MrsSCB

    pomelo / 5257 posts

    @bluestriped bee: no, he was definitely against leaving, so I'm assuming that's why he's stepping down. The leader of the pro-Brexit faction apparently said of Cameron, "not a bad guy, just on the wrong side," or something to that effect.

  38. MrsSCB

    pomelo / 5257 posts

    @Cherrybee: I just read this morning that a lot of people are angry at pollsters for not "predicting" this. Which seems ludicrous, because the polls were within four percentage points of the result. That's pretty darn close! It's just that those four points meant one way or the other. If a person didn't vote because polls told them remain would win, who's the real idiot? Certainly not the polls...

  39. Mrs. Lemon-Lime

    wonderful pea / 17279 posts

    Whoa! The ramifications of that vote sent shockwaves through the global financial markets. I hope the divorce isn't as painful as seeing red everywhere on Friday.

  40. MrsB2012

    nectarine / 2466 posts

    I think it's really unfortunate that so many people claimed to have voted in a way where they didn't understand what they were actually voting for. It just goes to show you really really need to educate yourself before you do go and vote ( on anything! ) I do commend the voter turnout, 77% is a pretty decent number. ( Well, at least compared to here, Canada, where voter turn out is usually quite poor in comparison. )

    My moms side is British, all of her direct family live in Canada now, but all of her extended family live in the U.K. It sounds like they were for the Briexit ( however, the ones that had emailed my grandpa about it, are the older generation, which fits with the voting scheme. )
    However, my cousin, who is Canadian, is in the process of getting her citizenship ( her dad was born in England, so she can get citizenship.) Her fiance is British, they've been trying to decide where they want to set their roots down. It sounds like they were swaying towards England, but now after this, they said they are definitely coming back to Canada. They're both quite political, head strong people who were 100% against leaving, it's actually quite sad to hear about it all now.

    I think it will be interesting to see how this all plays out. With it being such a close vote, with the reaction of the results, and how upset so many people are, if they will try and do anything ( or if they can do anything about it now.)

Reply »

You must login / Register to post

© copyright 2011-2014 Hellobee