What is your favorite long sleeve bib for starting solids? We are doing BLW and C is doing great, but my god, the mess. And she is just getting started.

I'm going to get her a long sleeve bib, trying to decide which one is best. I know the Ikea ones are popular, but aren't waterproof. Based on the juice running down her face eating her pear last night, I think waterproof is a must. Looks like Bumkins tie in the back and Green Sprouts velcro-- which is better?

C is 6 months and pretty little (about 16 lbs) but I hope she can use it past a year.