How did you decide on your crib mattress? I know I want a lightweight foam mattress, 5" or so thick. The lady in BBB recommended the Night Night 5" Crib Mattress for $119, which happens to be 'Green Guard Certified" (something with indoor air quality). Lucie's List recommends a regular Safety First foam one that is currently $39, it says nothing about anything green.

Do I care? Did you? That's a big price difference. I mean, the baby will be sleeping in it for a couple of years, then hopefully the next baby, so I don't mind paying up a bit for a good one, but at the same time, I don't want to pay up for pretty much the same exact thing.

Thoughts? We are getting a regular Pali crib so I'm assuming any standard crib mattress will fit.