GOLD / pineapple / 12662 posts
@HLK208: I see it sometimes at my daycare center, too (but usually it's the older child in the car). . . but the *decisions* we see come from a very different reality . . . one where the parents feel comfortable and safe, and are merely doing it for convenience as opposed to necessity.
wonderful pear / 26210 posts
@Mae: When your child is born, report back to me please about dropping off to a random center that you've never used before. I am curious how that is going to go for you.
Seriously, people. I want to know which ones of you would use a drop in center you've never visited before.
papaya / 10343 posts
@looch: Rather than leave my kid alone in a hot car for an hour in direct sunlight?? Unless I lose all common sense when my water breaks, I can't imagine my answer on this is changing.
GOLD / wonderful coffee bean / 18478 posts
@HLK208: ditto. I am in the minority in bringing my baby into preschool drop off. Most parents do choose the more convenient route of leaving the baby, but I can't do it.
Anyway, this is a different scenario and I really feel for her, but I do not agree with leaving your kids in the car, ever.
wonderful grape / 20453 posts
I have zero sympathy for anyone who leaves a human or pet in a hot car.
Leaving them in the crib at home for an hour would've been a safer option.
@looch, i would, if i was desperate for someone to watch my kid for only one hour and the alternate was no one and/or leaving them in a car
pomegranate / 3791 posts
@looch: So you would leave your 6 MONTH OLD and 2 year old alone in a hot car for almost an hour before leaving them at a center with people you don't know?? The first is a hell of a lot more likely to result in death than the second, so that truly astounds me.
ETA: And I do have a child that has already been born, although this would have baffled me just as much when I was pregnant. Doesn't change a thing about my thoughts on this. Do you know what kids that die in hot cars go through? It's one of the worst things, I can't imagine putting my baby in that situation.
bananas / 9899 posts
@looch: If it was my only option, I would definitely do it. I'm not going to leave my kids to potentially die in the hot sun. If those are my only two options, surely the daycare is the safer, more responsible choice.
There isn't anything else we can do to help this woman except offer a free place to drop off her kids. If her situation is this desperate I think she needs to take what she can get. If this free daycare service is available to her, there is no excuse for her leaving her children in her car.
GOLD / pineapple / 12662 posts
@wonderstruck: That's not what @Looch: said . . . she merely asked a question about using an unfamiliar center.
pomegranate / 3791 posts
@MsLipGloss: But we're not talking about normal circumstances here. We're talking about things someone desperate for childcare could do that would be preferable to leaving your babies alone in a hot car. Saying it's just a question about using an unfamiliar center completely disregards what the entire thread is about.
grapefruit / 4442 posts
@wonderstruck: I agree that she needs to plan these things out, but if you were in a desperate situation and needed the job, I'm sure you would think about childcare after you get the job.
My BFF said why didn't she reschedule her interview so she could find a sitter and my response was what if she got an interview for a job that hires the first qualified person and if she rescheduled she missed her opportunity to put food on the table and a roof over her head.
GOLD / pineapple / 12662 posts
@wonderstruck:I was just pointing out that you were making an assumption/drawing a conclusion from a question.
bananas / 9118 posts
@looch: compared with leaving them alone either at home or in a hot car alone- heck yeah I would definitely choose a well known day care center! These day cares do this as a marketing scheme to hopefully get the parents to sign their kids up for the long term once they get the job. They have 25 locations throughout our area, they have a good reputation here and are all over the media- definitely beats the alternatives.
Sure mine would have a fit at first, but 2 year olds don't really have that long term of a memory yet, I hardly think an hour or two would scar him for life
Yes, hopefully with some counseling and education she can get her kids back, but she is now in a far worse legal situation than she was before being unemployed.
squash / 13764 posts
@looch: I would also choose day care center over leaving them in the car--free, supervised care, as opposed to illegal, unsafe situation? No brainer. I'd rather have my kid hysterically crying in a daycare for an hour than leave him in a hot car.
That being said, I don't know this woman's history or background, so maybe for her own reasons she didn't feel comfortable with it. I know when I worked with mentally ill people living in poverty (not that she is mentally ill, it's just the population I had experience with), many of them were reluctant to use services that were available to them, either because they didn't like having their business aired out in public or the effort to engage in these services seemed to be too much. In this situation though, when it's between overcoming those things or putting your kids in danger, I don't think it's a tough choice (for me). I can have sympathy for her, but also think that what she did was wrong.
pomegranate / 3791 posts
@MsLipGloss: I'm not making an assumption. I'm reading the thread and using the context of it, as are all the other people who read it the same exact way as me. If someone asks what other options there are instead of leaving the kids in the car, people bring up a day care center, and they're told that they only think that because their kid isn't born yet and ask who of us would seriously leave our kids at an unfamiliar daycare center... Well, the daycare center was being discussed as another option instead of leaving your kids in the car. It's not like daycares were randomly being discussed here. It truly seems like you're just trying to start an argument over nothing.
wonderful pear / 26210 posts
I am just asking if you'd use a center you'd never used before, not whether you'd use a car as a day care center.
Even if YOU as a parent would, what if your kid screams so badly the entire time, that they call you back to get him? I am guessing none of you have experienced this? I have, and it's not pretty!
In any event, I'd take my kids into the interview with me as an alternative. As a mother myself, I'd totally respect someone who did that. I might not offer them the job, but that's using your brain.
pomegranate / 3003 posts
While she made a very unfortunate, dangerous decision that I personally do not agree with, I feel horrible for this woman. It is clear she feels the same.
I think most of us exist somewhere on the very large spectrum of "comfortable" - we can either stay home with our children, utilize familiar and preferred daycare/backup sitters, or coordinate with a partner/coparent, so we may keep crucial appointments. I personally wouldn't feel comfortable leaving my daughter at a drop-in service. Then again, it's not likely a choice I'd have to make.
I'm hesitant to pass judgement. Yes, she put her children in grave danger, but I'm willing to bet it was a poor, snap decision made in hopes of creating a better life for her family.
wonderful pear / 26210 posts
@wonderstruck: Nice conclusion drawing! You win the prize today.
Seriously, when you do a drop off at a center you've never used, please report back on how it went. Maybe your kid won't react, I don't know...but mine did and it wasn't a viable option.
pomegranate / 3791 posts
@looch: I'm completely lost on why you and Lipgloss have both decided to zone in on me despite the fact that there are several other posts that read your question the exact same way I did. It's not a very drastic conclusion when you're reading a thread about leaving kids in a hot car and talking about alternatives. Many of us (pretty much everyone besides you two) read the question that way. Seems like the logical way to read it in the context of the thread.
wonderful pear / 26210 posts
@wonderstruck: because you put the internet equivalent of words in my mouth.
It's just not that simple to say, oh here's free daycare, I am going to use that! It might not work out and just because this woman is in the situation that she's in doesn't mean she's got to use options she might not feel comfortable with. Have you tried a drop off center? Do you have first hand experience with that?
GOLD / pineapple / 12662 posts
@wonderstruck: Yep, completely lost. I totally agree with you there.
bananas / 9899 posts
@looch: "Just because this woman is in the situation that she's in doesn't mean she's got to use options she might not feel comfortable with."
I'm sorry, it does. If she literally tried everything else and had no other place to leave her kids for 2 hours, then her only options were leaving them at this daycare or taking them in to the interview with her. Leaving her young babies alone, unattended, in a hot car for over an hour is not a valid option.
Also, what else can be done? If even free childcare isn't help enough I'm not sure what else we can do.
eggplant / 11716 posts
I feel sorry for her. What a heartbreaking situation to be in.
I don't know anything about where she lives or what kinds of drop-off daycares are available and how far in advance you have to sign up for them (I'm sure you have to fill out paperwork and give notice you are bringing an extra child, so they can be in compliance with state child/teacher ratios).
But I understand the desperation. I read news reports all the time about moms leaving their babies with random neighbors or boyfriends, and usually it's in the news because the baby has died from shaken baby syndrome or something. We have a serious child care problem in this country. Child care is not affordable in many areas unless people are middle class and up. It's horrible and something our country needs to work on.
In the meantime, this mom needs a parenting class and some social service support.
grapefruit / 4066 posts
I do feel badly for this woman if this was truly her absolutely only option and she was that desperate. However, according to the other article the 6 month-old was wearing two T-shirts, one w/long sleeves, and was covered with a blanket. The temperature was 88 and she parked in direct sunlight. The driver's door was UNLOCKED and they found the keys in the ignition. A normal person does not do this!!! Absolutely no common sense was used whatsoever. If she felt like leaving her kids in the car was the ONLY option, for F's sake don't cover your baby with a blanket and put him in long sleeves and park in the sun!!!! And with her keys in the ignition, someone could have easily drove off with her kids and she could have never seen them again. I DO think her kids should be taken from her until she is able to take care of them. Something way worse could have happened.
@looch: I would have no option using a drop in center if I had no family or anything else near by, and I had a 1 hour job interview.
honeydew / 7504 posts
@looch: I have a hard time believing that you'd feel more comfortable leaving your babies alone in a car in 80+ degree weather than taking them to a drop-in center for an hour. Faced with NO OTHER options, like this woman may have been, are you seriously telling us you'd rather risk them sweltering to death in a car than crying for an hour in a safe place?
cantaloupe / 6885 posts
@lawbee11: agreed - her mug shot is devestating.
I would never do that - but that's easy for me to say as someone with the financial means to provide for my child, valid childcare options and emotional support from my husband, parents , sisters, friends, etc.
bananas / 9899 posts
"However, according to the other article the 6 month-old was wearing two T-shirts, one w/long sleeves, and was covered with a blanket. The temperature was 88 and she parked in direct sunlight. The driver's door was UNLOCKED and they found the keys in the ignition."
Uhm, wow if that's all true.
pomegranate / 3791 posts
@NovBaby1112: Oh, wow. So it sounds like there are bigger problems at play here. Honestly, I think she should probably be screened to see if there's any sort of mental illness going on, in which case obviously she's going to need some assistance to get that under control to properly care for her children.
grapefruit / 4066 posts
@pui: @wonderstruck: yep, was in the article @mslipgloss posted! http://www.firstcoastnews.com/story/news/crime/2014/03/22/kids-hot-car-job-interview/6730039/
wonderful pear / 26210 posts
I have tried a drop off center. My son cried the entire time and they called me to come and get him because they couldn't care for the other children with his screaming. I think they were worried he was going to stop breathing.
I wouldn't leave him in the car, I would take him with me if I had no other options. I have already written that above, @littlebug.
papaya / 10343 posts
@wonderstruck: agree, obviously.
@pui: Yep.
@Anagram: Totally agree. More options should be available. (but if they're not, endangering your kid does not become a valid option-- as I think you agree from your post)
@looch: If your point above, like you said, was that her best option was to take her kids with her to the interview, then I think that is totally valid. Leaving them at the daycare vs. taking them with you to an interview is a total judgment call based on you knowing your kid/your comfort level/what the center is like and I don't think anyone would fault her for taking her kid to the interview. I just don't think that came across in your initial post, it sounded like you were saying what she did was okay because the daycare might have been a bad option, and that is what @wonderstruck: and myself and everyone else was reacting to. Given the choice between making your kid really really angry by putting them in an unfamiliar daycare for an hour (and risking getting a call to come pick them up, which is an inconvenience) vs. leaving your kid in a hot car parked in direct sunlight for an hour when it is 88 degrees out… it is a no brainer. Unhappy kids calm down. Kids that die can't be fixed. But I agree, taking them to the interview with her would've been a totally valid option.
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21628 posts
I feel awful for her. It seems like she was in a desperate situation. She looks devastated. I can't say what I would do in the same situation, because I doubt I'd ever be in the same situation.
wonderful pea / 17279 posts
I don't know if this would have helped or hurt her in the interview, but in a child care lurch I say bring the kids to the interview.
grapefruit / 4291 posts
Whilst I definitely don't condone this mother's actions perhaps rather than crucifying this poor woman we should be using this incident as an opportunity to improve her circumstances and the support networks in place for others in a similar situation!
I'm also willing to bet the very few of us here on HB have ever been in a situation that would warrant us making such a decision...
We've all made poor decisions in our lives and like my Grandmother always said - there but for the grace of God, go I!
GOLD / watermelon / 14076 posts
Heard an interesting update on the radio this morning. A NJ woman set up a fundraising website and has raised over $100K for Shanesha Taylor.
papaya / 10343 posts
@lawbee11: Wow, that's sort of surprising! Hopefully she can use part of that money to take some parenting safety classes or counseling or something, and obviously buy her some help and time to get a job and child care and get on her feet.
GOLD / watermelon / 14076 posts
@Mae: I think a lot of people can relate to her. That's what I gathered from the comments left on the donation website.
Today | Monthly Record | |
---|---|---|
Topics | 1 | 0 |
Posts | 0 | 1 |
Ask for Help
Make a Suggestion
Frequently Asked Questions
Bee Levels
Acronyms
Most Viewed Posts
Hellobee Gold
Hellobee Recipes
Hellobee Features
Hellobee Contests
Baby-led Weaning
Bento Boxes
Breastfeeding
Newborn Essentials
Parties
Postpartum Care Essentials
Sensory Play Activities
Sleep Training
Starting Solids Gear
Transitioning to Toddler Bed
All Series
Who We Are
About the Bloggers
About the Hostesses
Contributing Bloggers
Apply to Blog
Apply to Hostess
Submit a Guest Blog
Hellobee Buttons
How We Make Money
Community Policies