Hellobee Boards

Login/Register

what age is too old for breastfeeding for you?

  1. Kemma

    grapefruit / 4291 posts

    Miss A is still nursing once a day at 2.5 (just before her nap) but I feel like she'll probably wean once she drops her nap and starts afternoon preschool in the next six months, so my "cutoff" age is 3-4. Fortunately Miss A has always had pretty good nursing manners and isn't interested if we're not home which has no doubt made it easier for me to continue bf'ing her.

  2. jedeve

    pomegranate / 3643 posts

    I think I would be happy to nurse until around 2. But we will just see!

    I think it's funny though when people say "when they can ask for it they are too old!" Um, babies ask for it from day one. Their language just evolves!

  3. CRGmama

    apricot / 324 posts

    We were both done at 8.5 months. I personally didn't ever love breastfeeding but I hope to have a better experience next time. Even still, I don't think I would continue too far after age one. Maybe 13-14 months.

  4. anonysquire

    cantaloupe / 6923 posts

    We're the last of our friends/family still nursing at 13 months. I don't know how old is too old for me. we will try for 2 and see how it goes.

  5. Orchid

    clementine / 927 posts

    3ish I think. I want to at least make it to 2. People think that's crazy and it boggles my mind since the WHO recommends breastfeeding until at least 2. I have to keep telling family members that and it drives me crazy.

  6. mamabolt

    nectarine / 2797 posts

    LO will be 3 in June and we are stopping then. We've started talking about how she won't get any more milkies after she turns 3. Never thought I'd find myself nursing 3 years but we just kept going and she never lost interest.

  7. JerricaBenton

    pomegranate / 3872 posts

    Maybe 4? LO is still nursing at 27 months but I think she'll quit before 3.

  8. erinpye

    pomegranate / 3706 posts

    For me, close to 2. I weaned my first at 8.5 months, and remember thinking she seemed way too old and too big to nurse at 22 months old, when I brought her sister home and she was super curious about watching her sister nurse. I'm still nursing my youngest at 14 months, and she doesn't seem too big yet, so maybe I just felt that way because it had been so long since I'd nursed my eldest.

  9. katsupgirl

    nectarine / 2280 posts

    I guess 4. My 2.5 year old is still going strong. I like the way we can have conversations about nursing. She sings songs about her "mama milk" and yesterday said she was going to drink mama milk forever. Oh dear!

  10. namaste

    persimmon / 1313 posts

    I'm thinking if we make it to one, I'll be OK.

  11. Peasinapod

    clementine / 770 posts

    My goal is one. I'd go as long as two if she seems to still really need it. At 7 months I just can't imagine not... But being able to drink whatever I'd like and have my body back is starting to sound appealing.

  12. ScarletBegonia

    persimmon / 1339 posts

    He self weaned at 10 months (or went on a nursing strike which I was not interested in pushing through) and that felt plenty long for me. Since he was borderline failure to thrive, I found that I was able to relax so much more knowing how many mls he was getting, rather than constantly worrying about my supply. And what do you know, he started stacking on the weight when he went on formula/cows milk. Honestly I wish we'd stopped earlier as it had become a source of stress for my family.
    That said, without the weight gain/supply issues I would have probably kept going til 13/14 months maybe? I was definitely ready to have my body back and not worry about taking medications and drinking. I just got over a terrible cold and it was SO nice to be able to take all the super strength drugs again!

  13. californiadreams

    pomegranate / 3411 posts

    after breastfeeding for 2 years and 2 months and knowing i could have went longer, it is hard to answer. Before i got that far, i probably would have said less than that. I weaned at that time because i was TTC and i am still not pregnant, so i kind of wish i let him self-wean. i now plan to do that with #2 whenever that may be!

    so for now my short answer is high school

  14. Applesandbananas

    pomegranate / 3845 posts

    Maybe 3

  15. lilteacherbee

    cantaloupe / 6791 posts

    I don't know, maybe somewhere between 18-24 months for myself. My LO self-weaned at 13 months and my goal was a year. I would have gone longer if he had still been interested.

  16. Sapphiresun

    nectarine / 2220 posts

    I dried up at 15 months. I think whatever works for other moms and babies is great, but for me, when I look at my now 21 month old I feel like it would be a little uncomfortable to be nursing her still. But maybe if next baby is a little more calm/cuddly I'd feel differently.

  17. photojane

    cantaloupe / 6164 posts

    My cutoff is 12-15 months. I never nursed, but I wouldn't have nursed longer than 15 months. I would've weaned as soon as my LO was drinking enough whole milk (just like I weaned the formula).

  18. Baby Boy Mom

    pomegranate / 3983 posts

    @T.H.O.U.: thanks! It almost seems like no big deal now, but our early days were such a huge struggle that I'm so thankful to have pushed through.

  19. meredithNYC

    pomegranate / 3314 posts

    Probably around a year for me? I just think I would want my body back by that point - particularly if we decide to try for LO #3 when #2 is a year old.

  20. CakeLady

    pear / 1657 posts

    I'm not really sure. DS is 11 months this week and we are still nursing often. He's been sick a lot and we have had some major setbacks with solids, so I expect I will keep nursing a while longer. I'm pretty sure I'll want to stop by 2, but maybe not.

  21. littlebug

    honeydew / 7504 posts

    We weaned at 14 months. That was good for me. Sometimes I missed it, up until about 18 months or so. So I guess I could go to 18 months. After that I think I'd be done. I don't really judge anyone who breastfeeds longer, but it's not for me.

  22. BKCaribBaby

    pear / 1672 posts

    I’m about to wean a 25 month old. That said, we’ve only done about once per day right after she wakes up since about 16 months. Lately she’s so busy she sometimes that she forgets. I’ve gone back and forth about how I feel about it since 18 months. I’m ready now though. I don’t think I would want to do this past 3.

  23. autumn865

    persimmon / 1147 posts

    I would say personally 2 would probably be my limit. DD1 self weaned at 14 months and I was ok with it.

  24. Pirouette

    pomegranate / 3331 posts

    Before having lo, I would've said a year. We're still nursing twice a day at 16 months and I'd like to wean fully by 18 months, but that's not because it's too old, just because I think it'll help her gain weight and I'm done. I've been pretty surprised by how many "you're STILL breastfeeding?!?!" comments I've gotten, especially from moms. I don't have a magic age in mind

  25. sarac

    pomelo / 5093 posts

    It's funny - when I weaned my daughter at 28 months, she didn't seem too old at all. I was just sick of it. But now I see children that age and think that they're way too old. Funny how your perspective shifts.

  26. 2littlepumpkins

    grapefruit / 4455 posts

    @stargal: I think for me, maybe 18 months. Just personal preference. If I could do just bedtime maybe that could go longer. If lo wanted to nurse frequently after a year Id honestly be more likely to want to wean. If it was infrequently I would feel like I'm giving less of my body up then I'd be more likely to stick with it. I think by 18 months (plus pregnancy) i would selfishly just want my body to myself.

  27. fairy

    persimmon / 1343 posts

    Every kid is different, so I can't say I have a cutoff, maybe like kindergarten. My daughter is turning 2 next month and still nurses at least 4 times a day (she "still" nurses to sleep and for nap, too) and I don't really see an end in sight yet with her. She is very attached to it and asks for "mook" often especially if she is upset or tired. I never had a goal in mind, but I didn't really expect her to still be nursing - I thought she would lose interest somewhere around 18m but it never happened!

Reply

You must login / Register to post

© copyright 2011-2014 Hellobee