I'm in the very beginning stages of planning a teeny minication for DH and I for our 5 year wedding anniversary coming up. Because it's in August and smack in the height of wedding season around here I want to book our hotel room ASAP. We'll be staying overnight at a hotel locally.

I am torn between what hotel I should book

My options are:
A) locally owned hotel that's in a renovated historic building. Within the building there are 4 amazing restaurants that go from a brewery to fine dining. All highly reviewed and locally owned and a local coffee / bake shop.
But because it's a locally owned hotel the amenities are not as vast as a national chain. No room service and I'm sure the rooms are a bit smaller.
But the beauty of this choice is we can literally stay our entire 30-40 some odd hours in this building and never leave if we wanted to. DH won't have to drive at all, which I'm sure will be amazing for him.

Or b) a vast selection of national chains which will have likely bigger rooms. More amenities and room service!!! But DH will likely have to drive us to get lunch, dinner, etc. but everything will be only 5-10 minutes away.

We are looking to just spend quality time together sans kids. Sleep!!!

If you've done a overnight trip before what would you choose for a overnight stay in your own city?

Local hotel is about the same price as all the national chains.