Hellobee Boards

Login/Register

All plastic is bad. This is very concerning....

  1. Mrs. Chipmunk

    blogger / clementine / 998 posts

    @mrslilybugg I've only ever sterilized my pump parts and bottles the first time, but that's just me. My ped agrees that sterilization stems from back when we all were on well water and it's not really necessary anymore. The way I justified it to myself was that my boobs were anything but sterile, and the drying racks that people use to dry the parts on are far from Sterile (and often harbor mildew and mold), so I don't boil.

  2. lamariniere

    pineapple / 12566 posts

    @yoursilverlining: re: baby cups in Europe. Almost all of the baby cups (and bottles, pacis, etc.) I see here are US brands like Avent, Playtex, Munchkin, etc. I'll start to look out for non-US/non-made in China products though.

    I'm slowly eliminating plastic in the kitchen. For example, I got really freaked out about our electric tea kettle that was almost all plastic and found one that is all metal except for the water gauge. Glass storage containers are hard to find and expensive here, but I want replace our plastic containers little by little.

  3. SugarplumsMom

    bananas / 9227 posts

    @HabesBabe: I'm with you, too.

  4. looch

    wonderful pear / 26210 posts

    @lamariniere: that is interesting, because I found there was very little plastic in our day to day lives because there are no facilities to recycle plastic...is that the same where you live?

    For example, we used to buy yogurt in glass jars and there are none of those deli containers available.

    As for our Avent bottles, the ones we had were manufactured in England!

  5. Crisark

    pomegranate / 3398 posts

    @.twist.: Agree with everything you've posted.
    There will be no change here.

  6. wonderstruck

    pomegranate / 3791 posts

    I really just can't even bring myself to get worked up about this. I guess I'm just one of those 'thoughtless' people, but there are studies out there that say practically everything on the freaking earth is or might be bad for us. I do what I can to protect my child and keep him healthy - extended rear-facing car seat, lots of sunscreen, zero exposure to cigarette smoke, etc., but I cannot and will not spend my life worrying and driving myself crazy over every single research study. That kind of stuff can just take over your entire life if you let it and turn you into a completely paranoid person. I mean, some of the more mommy wars baiting posts here seem to imply that if I'm going to keep using my bpa-free plastic bottles I might as well just take up smoking and start doing that around my baby too.

    Making these changes is expensive, and in my honest opinion, unnecessary. Everything can be dangerous - glass can break and injure my child. Some kinds of metal contain SSIGs, which some studies link to alzheimers. Ever painted the house while your child is home or had them in the house soon after? Hope it was VOC free because otherwise you could be triggering asthma and affecting everyone's reproductive health - and getting carpet installed often causes VOC odors too. Ever used PVC on a project in your home? Well, the dust it releases when being cut or shaved can cause cancer and neurological issues. Do you have any pressed wood in your house? The glue holding pressed wood together sometimes contains a chemical that causes cancer and asthma! Do you own a laser printer? It releases compounds that have been linked to heart and lung disease.

    I could go on and on and on, but I think you get the idea - and we all know that the second you think you've made everything safe, there will be a new study telling you that you're wrong. I do what I can to give my child a safe environment, but I assess risks and refuse to fear basically the entire world. Particularly when it's based on a limited amount of evidence based on animals, with little to no complaints of people actually getting sick.

  7. SugarplumsMom

    bananas / 9227 posts

    @lamariniere: Can you please link your electric tea kettle. I need to replace ours.

    @looch: yogurt in glass jars - that's awesome! Plastic is pretty common here, but a ton of lined/treated paper containers.

  8. mamimami

    grapefruit / 4120 posts

    @MrsLilybugg: Gah that is one of the first things I thought... I no longer use bottles and sterilize but when I did for both kids... sterilizing plastic bottles inside of a plastic container inside of a microwave. Like, cancer wrapped up in ambiguous sexual organs with a side of infertility....

    Fortunately our bottle days are over, but we still have a lot of plastic in our lives. I will do my best to find alternatives but to me the thing that was so concerning (tho I guess not surprising) about the article is the amount of deception of the public. To me, that was the point of the article, really. It's so hard to know what is safe and unsafe.

    As @bluestriped bee mentioned about Vietnam, I live in a developing country where there is little awareness even about BPA. Like, in Mexico they're just now getting on the BPA-free bandwagon. Have people been perfectly happy and content using BPA-laden plastics? Of course, they have no idea. However, does that mean that a few years down the line, they won't have the health problems associated with BPA and whatever else? I wouldn't put any money on that as this is sort of a multigenerational problem according to the research. Remember that plastics were not used on a wide scale in developing countries as early as they were in the US.

  9. MrsLilybugg

    pear / 1650 posts

    @MrsMccarthy: thanks! stupid question: how sturdy are glass bottles? And are they heavy? Are they appropriate for a 7 month old? the idea scares me! but so does plastic.
    @Mrs. Chipmunk: you are SO RIGHT. I mean, I sterilize the parts and it's not like I transport them in sealed sterile bags - I stick them right back into the cooler that I brought the used parts home in. Ha.
    @wonderstruck: sigh. This is so true too. (the "everything is dangerous")
    @mamimami: AAAAAAAAAA put that way, DEFINITELY no more sterlizing in plastic in microwave for me either!!!

  10. lamariniere

    pineapple / 12566 posts

    @looch: we have plastic recycling and there is still a surprising amount of plastic in the day to day. At the supermarket half of the produce is sold prepackaged in those plastic containers, which drives me crazy, and for yogurt, maybe only 20% of the selection is in glass.

    @SugarplumsMom: I couldn't find a link, but the brand is Trisa (Swiss). I remember that Delonghi had some cool design-y all metal ones, but they were more than I wanted to pay.

  11. kiddosc

    grapefruit / 4278 posts

    I think it's important to look at all the research and especially to consider the source before throwing out all plastics. There are many studies being done on the effects of BPA, and while they are finding detrimental effects, those are being noticed at very large doses. 70,000 times what a typical American ingests, according to this article from NPR. http://www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/2014/02/26/283030949/government-studies-suggest-bpa-exposure-from-food-isn-t-risky

    The article references this study. http://toxsci.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2014/02/20/toxsci.kfu022.abstract

    BPA has been extensively studied by the FDA and the European Food Safety Authority. While it's smart to limit it, I don't think at this point, limited exposure is something to get overly worked up about.

  12. meganmp

    persimmon / 1420 posts

    @wonderstruck: You are my hero for this post. I've been feeling like a bad parent because I just can't handle changing our plastic use, on top of everything else. Now I feel better!

  13. littlebug

    honeydew / 7504 posts

    @wonderstruck: You summed up everything I was thinking perfectly! Everything in life has risks - I could get hit by a car while walking to work today. Not to mention, opinions on this stuff changes CONSTANTLY. Several years ago, we were being told to cut our coffee consumption because...I don't even remember. And then now we're told coffee is good because can help prevent Alzheimer's. So, basically, I think all things in moderation.

  14. Dandelion

    watermelon / 14206 posts

    @wonderstruck: Yep, agreed. I'm gonna pick my battles...this isn't one of them.

  15. autumnlove

    hostess / wonderful watermelon / 39513 posts

    I guess I worry a little and I will make some changes (I want glass tupperware) but I don't plan on replacing toys, cups, etc.

    I am pumping breastmilk into plastic bottles and freezing in plastic storage bags right now...eek

  16. Mrs. Chipmunk

    blogger / clementine / 998 posts

    @sugarplumsmom My parents, my aunt, and i all use this and we dont even drink coffee. It heats up really fast and we use it for tea and boiled water. http://www.amazon.com/Farberware-FCP240-2-4-Cup-Percolator-Stainless/dp/B00008ELEA/ref=sr_1_cc_3?s=aps&ie=UTF8&qid=1393957408&sr=1-3-catcorr&keywords=Faberware

  17. MsLipGloss

    GOLD / pineapple / 12662 posts

    @wonderstruck: Another case in point: wood vs. plastic cutting boards.

    http://faculty.vetmed.ucdavis.edu/faculty/docliver/Research/cuttingboard.htm

  18. mediagirl

    hostess / wonderful persimmon / 25556 posts

    @wonderstruck: totally agree. I read this post yesterday, went home and fed my kid her dinner on her plastic tray from the Target dollar spot. She also drank out of her plastic sippy cups. I do my part by only warming things in glass or ceramic but I'm not going out to replace everything I own because of one study. Everything could possibly give us cancer one day. I have enough things to worry about in my life, I don't need to add more.

  19. twinmama

    pear / 1723 posts

    We all make different choices and it's ok, we all have our LOs best interest in mind. We each have different priorities based on what is truly practical in our families. Not everyone can do everything, even if we knew what was truly ideal. It's just another lifestyle/parenting choice, like feeding, diapers, sleep, etc. You do what you can, try not to judge others for their priorities, and move on.

  20. Mrs. Sketchbook

    GOLD / nectarine / 2884 posts

    We try to live zero waste but that actually means we have more plastic in our life....because we can reuse it (example: yogurt tubs). I have wanted to upgrade to glass containers but we would need hundreds of dollars worth because we freeze a ton of food. For now I try to stick to containers marked with a 5, because 5 is supposed to be food safer than other types. But after reading this article I did drop by TJM today and got some glass containers; hopefully over time we can phase out the other stuff we have or use it only for freezing.

    I agree with other posters that you cannot avoid everything ; in fact , plastic is used in an attempt to avoid other problems (spoilage, bacteria, etc.) that I am sure caused serious health problems before plastic. That being said, only conscientious consumption will encourage companies to offer safer products so I like to buy for that reason. It is amazing what is on the market right now that wasn't available 20 years ago (even that plastic is labeled is amazing) and that is due to consumer demand.

    I am planning to buy LO some stainless plates and straws tonight!

    I try to steer clear from any plastic that is unlabeled, because that means it is a proprietary formula like triton or whatever tervis uses. Whereas the formulas for 1, 2, and 5 are standard and transparent. Not to mention non-labeled plastics aren't recyclable.

  21. twinmama

    pear / 1723 posts

    @Mrs. Sketchbook: That's really helpful to know about the 1, 2, & 5 plastics. Good guideline when plastic is necessary, like freezing!

  22. swurlygurl

    honeydew / 7091 posts

    I hate to bring this thread back to life (but not enough to shut up), but this article just popped up on my FB feed:
    http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2014/03/guide-estrogen-common-plastics-bpa
    I am 100% sure there is a better article out there with the same information, but the comments are cracking me up. I'm SO glad HB isn't so mean!

    It's another scare-the-reader article, but it was an interesting read to get me thinking about the different types of plastics and what they're made of. The article makes it seem as if styrofoam is actually better than most of the other plastics, and I would have said it was worse!

  23. looch

    wonderful pear / 26210 posts

    My opinion is this: it isn't a bad thing when people share information, but the message in which things are delivered often colors participation in ways we don't even think about.

    Could the OP have worded the thread title more neutrally? Yeah, probably. Could some of the posters posted their counteropinions more neutrally, yeah. It's a two way street.

  24. twinmama

    pear / 1723 posts

    Looks like snapware and take & toss plastic are both a 5....that helps

    FWIW, some of the takeaways from my research are to use alternatives (glass/stainless) for hot/acidic/oily items that are more likely to promote leaching, and for longer term storage like dry pantry staples. And to handwash plastics to reduce degradation. I can handle that!

Reply

You must login / Register to post

© copyright 2011-2014 Hellobee