I’m thinking I should take advantage of the money my insurance will pay towards a second pump so it’s one less thing to lug to and from work each day, but am undecided on which to get. I can purchase any pump I want (from anywhere) and submit the receipt for up to a $150 reimbursement.

I can’t decide between a second PISA (have one from my first LO) or the Spectra S1 or S2. On one hand, I already have all the parts for the Medela and won’t have to worry about what parts I have at work and what I have at home. But on the other hand, I’ve read really great things about the Spectra.

I figure they would cost me the same amount out of pocket, so that's not really a factor either way. PISA was a little more $$ but I won’t need to buy parts, whereas Spectra cost a little less but I will need to buy extra parts.

Does anyone have experience with both of these pumps, and if so, which do you prefer? Is the Spectra really as quiet as the reviews make it seem?

And....side question for Spectra users…..where do you buy your spare parts? I didn’t see much on Amazon, so that’s one concern I have about going with the S1 or S2. I'm not exactly sure what extras I'd need or where to get them.