Hellobee Boards

Login/Register

She pulled her boob out during mass!

  1. meredithNYC

    pomegranate / 3314 posts

    I definitely wouldn't do it myself, but I would be okay with it if I saw someone nursing in church.

  2. Pink Champagne

    clementine / 943 posts

    Awesome! I love seeing women who are bold enough to nurse in public without a cover. I am way too shy, but good for her!

  3. travelgirl1

    cantaloupe / 6630 posts

    Go her! I think covers can actually be more of a distraction, A kicks hers flying in rage, lol. Now I nurse wherever I need to, if I can be discreet, great, but if not, whatever.

  4. plantains

    grapefruit / 4671 posts

    Kudos to her for not feeling like she should be ashamed of feeding her child. I nursed LO during mass all the time, always with a cover because she tolerated it. I used a cover in public at all time because she let me, but if she hadn't I would have nursed her without.

    @mrsmenow: babies are all different, and if you are nursing on deman, feeding before may not work. Also, my LO was a bottle refuser so that wasn't an option for us. Nursing for us wasn't always about food anyway, more often than not, it was about comfort.

  5. mrsmenow

    persimmon / 1479 posts

    @plantains: I am well aware all babies are different, I have 3 of my own who are night and day of each other. I was just saying how I handled mass. It would make me personally uncomfortable-as I said I am really private about nursing. But whatever you gotta do to feed your baby go for it.

  6. plantains

    grapefruit / 4671 posts

    @mrsmenow: I'm sorry, I wasn't trying to offend you. I was just pointing out that lots of people need to nurse their babies for reasons other than food so it may not be feasible to look at nursing before or altering the times they attend mass per your suggestions.

  7. pinkcupcake

    cantaloupe / 6751 posts

    I personally wouldn't nurse without a cover but have no problem with anyone who does I nurse at church all the time but I always use a cover.

  8. littlebittyhouse

    pear / 1570 posts

    go mama! i was actually nursing my six week old during his christening. it was either nurse or have him scream. the priest didn't mind at all - in fact he told me that i was a great mother!

  9. cheert16

    nectarine / 2631 posts

    I wish I was comfortable enough to nurse in public (with or without a cover!) props to that lady!!

  10. Turd Ferguson

    pomegranate / 3160 posts

    @cmomma17: I was going to respond with the exact same thing! Amen!

  11. pastemoo

    cantaloupe / 6146 posts

    @Sugar.Biscuit: I haven't done it but I would like to think that when I have another I wouldn't worry about it.
    LO WILL NOT NURSE with a cover. And if it is
    a) nurse quietly
    b) nurse loudly with cover
    c) loudly leave to nurse (and trail 2 other kids along!)
    I couldn't choose b. I usually choose c and regret it. I missed a whole wedding this way because once I leave he won't go back in

    I would support whoever made any of those choices.

  12. Mrsbells

    squash / 13199 posts

    Many moms breastfeed at our church, they usually use a cover though, or sit in the back. Personally I dont think its an issue of people judging per se but it might distract people, Yes it is 100% natural to feed your baby but your breast is still a part of your body that you wouldnt normally expose to people so I think theres a fine line to straddle.
    I was never brave enough to breast feed at church I always pumped

  13. Sugar.Biscuit

    nectarine / 2063 posts

    Wow I didn't think this would get this big of a reaction. I wanted to come back and add a few things as I typed this up real quick this morning.
    For me:
    *The breastfeeding in public isn't the distraction its those who are distracted by it, that is the distraction. Which is why I encourage covers. I'm the type of person that doesn't like to stir things up so I'd rather avoid controversy. It sucks that people are so uncomfortable with what is natural. Honestly I'm still trying to get use to it myself. I'm sure it will change once the twins are here lol. DH did tell me I can't nurse during mass, oh darn Then again I'll hopefully be nursing for two & my boobs are HUGE so I would feel very exposed so I'm okay with that.

  14. LovelyPlum

    eggplant / 11408 posts

    Mmm, I'm not.sure. I support nursing in public, and it totally doesn't bother me to see women nurse without a cover almost anywhere,but I'm not sure about the front of church during Mass. I love families at Mass, and I hate saying babies should have to be confined to the cry room, but I'm just not sure about that one. Maybe that makes me a hypocrite, I'm not sure. But if you're asking for my honest opinion, there it is.

    Eta: maybe this will change when I have a fussy baby in church. Probably so. But this is where I am right now.

    I really don't mean to offend anyone, though.

  15. skibobrown

    pomegranate / 3388 posts

    Like others I think this is awesome! I never got to the point where I was comfortable nursing in public before I had to call it quits with breastfeeding, but I am totally fine when others feed their babies (by whatever means) in public. I mean, I fed my baby in public too... just with a bottle b/c I was unable to use my body to feed my child.

  16. evenstar982

    apricot / 284 posts

    I remember being mightily impressed at my friend (mother of 3) who was able to breastfeed during a church service, holding the baby with one hand while she followed her next youngest around the church during the middle of a service one week - and managed the entire thing without mishap/flashing! Kudos to that mama - doing what God designed her for while Worshipping Him; surely that's just awesome

    Not sure I will be *quite* so brave myself come September when our LO arrives though...

  17. Maysprout

    grapefruit / 4800 posts

    I chose to go to the baby room to nurse and no matter how we timed the feedings before it I almost always ended up there at some point. Ideally I would have preferred to stay but I was too self conscious because I was worried about what others would gossip.

    So I would have been very happy that this woman was staying and nursing since hopefully the more people who do it normalizes the behavior and makes it easier for other women and something less likely to be gossiped about.

    My older LO is distracted by everything a baby does so I wouldn't say nursing is a distraction for LO anymore than a baby's presence is distracting if it does anything more than lay there, so I don't think the distraction argument works. As for adults being distracted by it I understand it's something out of the norm but I can't really put together what is disrupting about someone sitting in a pew and nursing.

  18. tysonja

    nectarine / 2217 posts

    we have an awesome nursing room at our church -- it's pretty big, softly lit with couches and rocking chairs, and it's attached to the main sanctuary by a giant one sided mirror i love being in the service but able to eat my lunch/chat with the moms/AND nurse/change diapers all at once!

    that said, lots of moms just nurse in the service too, so they don't have to get up and come to the room

    i personally like using a cover for us because sometimes i don't wear very nursing friendly clothing to church, and also because me and LO were super clumsy breastfeeders haha.... popping off all the time! hehe

  19. Arden

    honeydew / 7589 posts

    Good for her! I think the mother's room/nursing room should be for the MOTHER'S comfort, not for everyone else's.

    And yes, I breastfeed in church, and anywhere else my baby happens to get hungry.

  20. Modern Daisy

    grapefruit / 4187 posts

    I'm pretty conservative so I would be bothered by it. But I would never say anything or get involved, I would just never do it myself.

  21. runsyellowlites

    coconut / 8305 posts

    @Arden: I totally agree! I don't know many moms that bf though so ours definitely feels the other way around!

    I think we forget that this would've been common practice back in the day. lol

  22. sslm

    cantaloupe / 6397 posts

    @Arden: totally agree! I sometimes use the nursing room at the mall bc it makes me more comfy.

  23. HLK208

    pineapple / 12234 posts

    I would cover but I don't care what anyone else does. I did when I was younger though!

  24. Mrs. Fox

    cherry / 208 posts

    I breastfeed everywhere so I'm pretty liberal about the whole thing and I applaud the mom. And while I'm not religious, I love the idea that that baby is literally drinking in the love, both of his mama and his community's faith. Talk about feeding body and soul!

  25. Penny Lane

    nectarine / 2163 posts

    Done it!

    I think our church meetings are a little different than the norm, in that we don't have nurseries during the "mass" type meeting. it's encouraged, even expected, that your children will be in there with you, as they need church as much as adults do. We do have cry rooms, but I've always thought of them as more for whiny toddlers than nursing babies.

    therefore I nurse regularly without a cover. shirt up, tank down, etc. so I say good on her!

  26. Vegmama

    pear / 1799 posts

    Good for her!

  27. PrincessBaby

    cantaloupe / 6610 posts

    Good for her! I wish I was that comfortable. I usually go to the bathroom or to a dressing room but that's not always convenient. Today H had a meltdown in Sbucks bc she was hungry but they only had 1 stupid bathroom and I didnt want to hog it for 10-15 mins so I gave her emergency formula I keep in the diaper bag. I WISH I felt confident enough to just whip a boob out and be like "I'm feeding my baby! Get over it! If you have a problem with it, you must me some kind of perve because otherwise you'd recognize that this is how our bodies work- breasts are feeding utensils. Just like forks/spoons/knives."

  28. googly-eyes

    GOLD / pomelo / 5737 posts

    I don't think to necessarily awesome, and I don't think it's bad. It's just feeding..

    The only way that this would really be a distraction to me is if she made a big scene of it. In church I would expect nursing to be discreet. Not needing a cover, just quietly done. I'd expect the same from an ff mom giving a bottle.

  29. MrsMccarthy

    honeydew / 7295 posts

    Good for her! Breasts are over sexualized in our society. They are made for feeding little babies.

  30. lomom

    nectarine / 2127 posts

    That's awesome! I would be thrilled to see a mom nursing during Mass.

    I wish nursing in public was more accepted. There's nothing sexual about using breasts for their biological function and nothing to be ashamed of. I think breastfeeding is hard enough on its own, without all the worries of judgement for when and where you find yourself needing to feed your child.

    I read a pro-breastfeeding blog about nursing in public and someone had commented that it was disgusting and she didn't want her husband and sons to see that. I hope my son is fortunate enough to learn that breasts are for nourishing babies and to have respect for women, that they're not sexual objects.

  31. Cherrybee

    papaya / 10570 posts

    I think it's awesome that she was able to nurse in church. I really, really hope that nursing in public is something I'm comfortable doing once my LO is here. It's not the boobs-are-sexual thing that worries me, it's the fact that my boobs are huge, saggy, veiny, stretch-marked monstrosities and I'm not sure I want to get them out in front of anyone bar DH (and not even him, really). I'm going to try to get over it though.

    I also feel the need to admit that prior to TTC (prior to reading HB, really) I thought that NIP was a bad thing and should be banned. I was disgusted when a client of mine "got her big, ugly boob out and then her baby starting sucking on it and drinking her bodily fluids" (that's how I perceived it and described it to friends who were equally horrified) during an interview with me and as for seeing it in restaurants where I might be eating - yuk!! I can see now that I was totally, totally in the wrong for feeling that way, I just grew up in a society where it wasn't done and I had never seen it before.... There I said it. I admitted it.

    So, yeah, that lady should be proud of herself! The more normalised it is in society, the better.

  32. Mrs D

    grapefruit / 4545 posts

    Gosh rarely do I find myself in the total minority here on the Bee but I would not have done this. I know everyone's choices are there own - but I guess I just keep thinking "would I eat in church" - like pull out a sandwich and have a meal...and the answer is a definite no. To me it has nothing to do with the cover or not (although - being honest I doubt I'll have the guts to nurse no cover in public and I doubt DH will be comfortable with me doing that either) - I guess it just seems inappropriate to eat in the middle of a church service.

    Having said that - I agree with others who have said they'd rather the baby get fed than be fussy. I guess if I was her I would have left to the nursery and nursed her in there or in the restroom - our church has amazing womens restrooms. It was a couple (if I remember correctly) so the partner could have stayed with the other two boys.

Reply

You must login / Register to post

© copyright 2011-2014 Hellobee