What did you all realistically take when you were TTC or pregnant and had a bad headache? My migraines are slightly better but I still get headaches a few times a week, so in an effort to avoid caffeine I've been trying to wean myself off Excedrin Tension Headache. Especially since I don't want to be on so much caffeine if/when we do IVF! Sometimes I think the caffeine might be causing rebound headaches.

Is there anything stronger than Tylenol but not an NSAID and not containing caffeine that works and is safe during this time?