What color should we paint our fireplace? I can't decide.

Thinking Welded Iron and Dark Granite are too dark and that Anonymous is too light. I think I like the other two equally though.

Eventually planning to replace our ugly mantle with a chunky dark wood one and Im thinking white/gray marble over the white brick and the tan mosaic on the floor.

First picture: welded iron, mansard stone, anonymous, suede gray, dark granite

Second picture: Mansard stone, anonymous, suede gray, welded iron, dark granite