So, apparently JLo isn't coming back to AI for a third season. Who would you want to replace her?
-
someone young. all the judges on ai are too old. steven tyler doesn't contribute much. jlo is the best judge out of the 3. i miss simon....
-
american idol isnt the same now without the original judges, honestly at this rate i wouldnt mind if the show was canceled
-
Somebody with an opinion!!!
-
I miss Simon! Jlo and Steven are too nice.
-
I'd like to register a vote for Justin Timberlake. I know he probably has better things to do, but still.....!
Edited: I just realized if JT joined, there'd be three male judges. So my official vote is to kick off Steven Tyler and add in Madonna. I'm sure she'd so be up for that, right?
-
@Mrs. Bee: I agree - and now with X Factor having Britney Spears and Demi Lovato, American Idol is going to become irrelevant (even moreso) if they don't get a new younger judge or two
-
@Mrsbells: ditto
-
@twodoghouse: I might actually tune in if JT was a judge, he's so yummy! haha
But I agree, they need younger talent, that is why X-Factor has a one up on them, they have both experience and younger judges to hit all demographics.
-
I also miss Simon. I'm not a jlo fan so I am really glad she isn't coming back!
Idk who I would want to replace her though. -
AI without Simon just isn't the same.
-
Someone mean. I think they're all just too nice now. Never thought I'd say that because I didn't like Simon.
Reply
Subscribe to our newsletter
- Google Plus
- Stumbleupon
- Twitter
- Facebook
- Pinterest
- Favorite0
11 comments