Hellobee Boards

I absolutely love NYR's eye make up remover. I've tried several & this is the one that completely removes everything, isn't greasy & doesn't leave a residue, which I hate.

https://us.nyrorganic.com/shop/corp/area/shop-online/category/eyes/product/1799/organic-eye-make-up-remover-3-38fl-oz/

This isn't eye-specific but I do use it for my eyes and it's AWESOME. I just bought it. It's Estee Lauder's "Take it Away" total makeup remover.

http://www.esteelauder.com/product/684/2196/Product-Catalog/Skincare/By-Category/Cleansers-Toners/Take-It-Away/Total-Makeup-Remover/index.tmpl

It looks and feels like a lotion (not transparent liquid), and you rub it into your dry face/lids and rinse or towel off.

I wear waterproof makeup everyday and I use Ponds Cold Cream. It's cheap and it gets the job done. I apply with cotton balls or a tissue.

coconut oil or pond's cold cream at night. if i need to remove makeup and then put it on again, i use lancome effacil oil free.

Lancôme bifacils. I've been using it over a decade!

Coconut oil! Pond's cold cream is great too. Prior to that, I used to use the neutrogena eye make-up remover.

I used Lancôme Bificil for YEARS and loved it. I was always afraid to try anything else because I was convinced it was the best until I tried....Up and Up from Target!!! It works just as well and soooo much cheaper. I was shocked!!!!

I actually find the Almay for waterproof (the oily one) works the best! I have had one or two dry cans before so I think it's just a bad batch. Other than that, the pink bottle of make up remover from MAC and Shu Uemura cleansing oils are about he only things I can get all the eye makeup off. The neutrogena wipes work too, but I need 1 sheets and it irritates my skin.

I also use Lancôme Bifacils. My mom always gives me her gift with purchase samples so I haven't bought a bottle... Ever!

I use Johnson's 3-in-1 wipes for removing everything; they're a makeup remover, cleanser and moisturiser in one. I don't wear waterproof mascara though, so don't know how effective they would be for that.

Another vote for cold cream! I use Nivea face cream, wipe it on, massage it all around my eye sockets then wipe it off with dry cotton wool. Works a treat, even on waterproof mascara!

I use Clinique's Take The Day Off Cleansing Balm... love it! It's a balm that turns into an oil and it just melts everything off my face (including my waterproof eyeliner and mascara).

Cliniques is the absolute best (the purple one). Sephora brand wouldn't remove my Lancombe waterproof mascara, and I find drugstore brands too irritating to my eyes (Lancombe Bifacil is the WORST if you have sensitive eyes, it burns like crazy!)

@fussygal: I use the liquid

I have sensitive eyes, so a lot of removers irritate my eyes. The only one that I use is the blue bottle Clinique Rinse-Off Remover. Sometimes I use babywipes though.

I am intrigued by the use of coconut oil. I hardly wear eye makeup, but I do use baby oil, which isn't terrible, but it isn't great. I need something slick so as not to damage my already sparse eye lashes.

I swear by Almay Eye Makeup Remover pads in the little jar. The blue one that moisturizes (not the purple variant). Gets everything off so easily, even the most stubborn, waxiest waterproof mascara.

I use the DHC cleansing oil for my whole face - i rub it on my eyes and face dry all over and rub it all in then rinse off. But for just eye makeup, I used the blue clinique (rinse-off?) for years and years but i found that Sonia Kashuk was really comparable!