I finally saw it on Netflix!
http://movies.netflix.com/WiMovie/Being-Elmo-A-Puppeteer-s-Journey/70166234

It was great! It really is amazing what can happen when you follow your heart.

My one caveat is that Elmo's puppeteer neglected his daughter when Elmo was really taking off... it was a good reminder that nothing can replace those magical childhood years with your kids. I guess that's the price that he paid for being Elmo.

Definitely check out the documentary if you have Netflix and are looking for a good movie! Charlie even watched the opening and there was just enough Elmo in it to pique his interest!