Hellobee Boards

Login/Register

Could you have a home birth?

  1. littlejoy

    pomegranate / 3375 posts

    @teawithpaloma: What also concerns me is that many women who choose unassisted birth have little to no prenatal care. They have no idea if the baby is healthy enough for a vaginal birth, if they have placenta previa, etc.

    I'm torn on judging these women, because most made the decision after experiencing a traumatic birth in a hospital setting. My first reaction is to cringe, and wonder why they don't seek the support of a loving midwife who would support them in their home setting.

  2. teawithpaloma

    apricot / 490 posts

    @littlejoy: Yes exactly! I am actually fine if you want to forgo ultrasounds (not for me) but basic monitoring can save your life and the baby's life. You don't have to judge but I probably would say something a few times to someone in my life or even a friend of a friend if I heard this was happening. I would show them this documentary on birth in Senegal and see if it changes their mind because they are essentially signing up for the same thing.

  3. avivoca

    watermelon / 14467 posts

    @littlejoy: I cringe too, but living where I do (Kentucky), I know that a lot of women in the rural areas do not have access to midwife care. I birthed in a hospital with a CNM, but I had to cross state lines because none of the hospitals in my city at the time employed CNM's and the professional midwives are not allowed hospital privileges. It's actually illegal for a professional midwife to attend a home birth. The closest hospital with a CNM was almost an hour away.

  4. littlejoy

    pomegranate / 3375 posts

    @avivoca: I can't imagine living in a place where I couldn't make choices for my own body/baby. I'm sorry you had to deal with that, but I'm so happy you were able to find a provider that supported you! My home state (Indiana) just started allowing CNMs at home births. It's great to see it changing.

  5. avivoca

    watermelon / 14467 posts

    @littlejoy: I had H in Indiana and I'm so pleased with the level of care I received from my midwives.

  6. Kemma

    grapefruit / 4291 posts

    @littlejoy: I fell down the rabbit hole of UC on mothering.com one night when I was up feeding Felix and I was just fascinated!

    I get the impression that a lot of women who opt to UC do so because they dont feel they have any other choice. Some of them have had traumatic hospital births in the past and no longer have any trust in the medical profession to treat them with respect and compassion, so UC is away for them to regain control and heal themselves, for want of a better word. Some of them just can't find a provider who is willing to work with them to achieve their desired birth so they just go completely off the grid.

    On one hand, I can't help but admire them for the confidence and faith they have in their bodies to deliver a baby without assistance but on the other hand I can't help but think they're being foolhardy and altogether too casual with their lives.

    As to the lack of prenatal care, from what I've read, a lot of the women have great trouble finding a Dr or midwife who is willing to deviate from the standard model of care. I've read stories of Ob's resorting to bully tactics when a woman refuses GD testing or ultrasounds, or just flat out refusing to keep them on has patients.

    To me, UC is just one bridge too far and surely it would be better for women to have access to medical professionals who will work with their preferences (where medically indicated, obviously) and be able to birth where they feel most comfortable, with the assistance of trained professionals, rather than limiting their choices and risking the health and wellbeing of mothers and babies.

  7. Mrswonderwoman

    cherry / 104 posts

    Absolutely yes. I had a home birth with my first, and I'm planning to do so again for my second, who is due next week. It isn't for everybody, though, and I think knowing your own comfort level, health risks, etc is important before you make the decision.

    For my first home birth, it was imperative to me to choose a midwife that was experienced because I was nervous about the whole thing going south. My midwife had done literally hundreds of home births, so I felt very comfortable with her. I had a pretty difficult labor and there were a few moments we did discuss transferring, but that was mostly just because things were moving slow and I was getting a bit tired. But dangit, I was determined! So even though DS was asynclitic and I was utterly spent, he was born safely at home at 38 weeks. DS was totally healthy and fine Keep in mind, I live literally 2 minutes from a great hospital, and we are good family friends with two of the OBs on call there, so....we really felt completely okay the whole time.

    This being my second home birth, I ended up switching midwives (for a variety of reasons) and while I'm still nervous, I at least have some idea of what to expect. And my doula the first time around encouraged me that number 2 would be easier if I didn't have to deal with poor baby positioning. So we are crossing our fingers for that!

Reply

You must login / Register to post

© copyright 2011-2014 Hellobee