I labored a lot in the tub and shower with my first but gave birth in the hospital bed, movie style. With my second I briefly expressed an interest in it, but everything went so fast they didn't even have time to fill up a regular tub for me to labor in, much less get ready to deliver in it! If we ever had a third I might try for that though.

Who had a water birth? If you had one in water and one not, how did they compare?