I was never a fan and I remember awhile ago that seemed to be the general consensus here as well..
Now that J is 2 and has likes/dislikes and opinions of his own, I find myself wanting to buy him clothes that I know he will like and get excited about. That means shirts with minions on them, elmo and curious george. It doesn't matter to me so much whether they're "cute" - because he gets so excited about them!
I have to say, this elmo tee from ON is pretty darn cute!