I'm making a BJ's list and have a coupon that's good on either!
-
lately I've actually been making my own - but if I had a coupon I'd likely choose organic
-
Heinz regular
-
@Mrs. Pen: you make your own? I'm impressed.
-
@swedishfish: I started only cause I'm on the whole30 - but it's WAY easier than I thought! Takes about 10 minutes?
-
Organic because it tends to have better ingredients.
-
Good old fashioned Heinz. We eat so little ketchup so I'm
Not worried about organic vs not -
We buy Whataburger ketchup! (So, not organic
)
-
Heinz only, I've never had another ketchup I like.
-
@Tidybee: my FIL puts ketchup on EVERYTHING. We go through a lot when the ILs are around.
@PurplePumps: I buy Heinz organic!
-
Regular heinz!!! I tried organic and did not like it.
-
Regular. I don't eat it and DH likes the classic stuff.
-
We use Annie's Organic ketchup and really like it!
-
Organic. The regular is too sweet for me. Trader Joe's is my favorite (but they don't have that at BJ's)
-
Heinz regular! I've tried some organic ones in the past and they just tasted like tomato paste to me.
-
@lawbee11: us too!
-
never heard of organic ketchup until now! so i voted regular
-
@Shutterbug: yes!!! Trader joe's ketchup is the best!!!
-
Organic, although regular ketchup tastes way better.
-
I usually buy Heniz but I also like the Whole Foods regular or organic
-
Simply Heinz- it doesn't have HFCS in it!
-
@swedishfish: well shoot! I had no idea that existed... I'm going to have to look for that next time I buy ketchup.
-
Don't think it's quite organic, but I get Simply Heinz. Tastes like the classic, but you can actually easily undestand the ingredient list.
-
@lavender: That's my fav!
-
Regular Heinz. I tried the Trader Joe's one and didn't care for it. @Boogs: @lavender: I did not know this Simply Heinz existed! I might get that next time.
@Mrs. Pen: Recipe for the homemade? I made my own once but it was a South Beach recipe and had Splenda in it, which isn't want I'm looking for.
-
I prefer organic (no HFCS and no GMOs) but it took some trial and error to find one we love. If you are stuck with a BJs size one it might be a pain.
-
@Foodnerd81: this is the recipe I use from the Well Fed cookbook. I love it! I used dates instead of figs - so it has no sugar (dates are the "sweetener").
http://theclothesmakethegirl.com/2014/03/06/wf2-recipe-kickass-ketchup/ -
We always get organic. Usually from trader joes.
-
Organic Heinz for the texture and taste!
-
Both! DH really likes Heinz, I honestly don't taste a difference with organic/non-hfcs, so we alternate as a compromise.
-
Just regular!
-
Regular...but I do like organic better. We just don't use it enough to care.
-
@lavender: Same! I couldn't taste the difference when I switched!
-
We use Simply Heinz. Not organic but no HFCS.
-
hurmm. I buy both.
-
Heinz! Straight up regular
-
Only Heinz.
-
I don't really eat it. I had to buy in a few months back when I was making a bbq brisket recipe and the sauce called for 1 cup of ketchup. I bought regular and the rest of it is still sitting untouched in the fridge.
-
@Mrs. Pen: @swedishfish: I voted "Bubbles" because I also make my own. It is really easy!
-
regular ketchup!
)
Subscribe to our newsletter
- Google Plus
- Stumbleupon
- Twitter
- Facebook
- Pinterest
- Favorite0
41 comments