I am thrown off when it is white and natural. I think it stems from childhood and we always had the minty green one!
-
Yes and I don't even like mint chocolate chip so I shouldn't care
-
I like white mint chocolate chip!
edit: I'm actually not a mint chocolate chip fan, but my DH likes it and he only eats the white kind!
-
Yes!
-
Yes! It is my absolute favorite but it has to be green. I'm always disappointed when I get a cone somewhere and it's white.
-
Ha, I like white mint chip. DH likes green!
-
Should totally be green! It's one of my favorite flavors, yum!
-
@MrsF: same!
-
Either way is delicious!
-
I have a weird thing about food coloring and will only eat white mint chip.
-
Yes! And I only eat green pistachio ice cream too! The white version just doesn't seem right.
-
nooo! i love breyers because it is white! mmm i want some now!
-
It was my favorite ice cream before I stopped eating chocolate. No matter what color.
-
No way. Breyers is the only mint chocolate chip that's worth eating and it's white.
-
Nope! Makes me realize how artificial it is.
-
Hmm, green-white doesn't matter to me. I just want it delicious
-
Nope I avoid colorings.
-
The only white mint-chip I"ve seen has been at Christmas, with candy cane pieces! So yes, it should definitely be green!
-
I didn't know it came on white
-
No. I make my own and it turns out slightly yellowish (from the egg). I am not a fan of food coloring (especially since Ellie has a dye sensitivity), and the real mint flavor is to die for! Anyone who thinks it needs to be green should come over some time and try some of mine.
-
Mmmmm yes green. I just sat down with a big bowl of green mint chocolate chip ice cream, opened up HB and this is the first thread I saw. Haha!
-
It's my favorite flavor!!! And it should be green
-
I avoid artificial coloring on everything but mint chocolate chip ice cream. Give me the green stuff!
-
I'm anti food coloring for everything BUT mint choc chip ice cream. It just isn't right unless it's green.
-
Yes and no. The green helps you know the flavor without any other cues, but natural white seems better for you. Either way, while I am not an ice cream fan, mint chocolate chip was always a favorite!
-
I can appreciate both, but feel like they taste slightly different from each other. I absolutely cannot get enough of candy cane ice cream, though - with green *and* red candy cane chunks.
-
It's so hard to find white, but I enjoy it so much more (maybe a mental thing since there is no artificial coloring).
Reply
Subscribe to our newsletter
- Google Plus
- Stumbleupon
- Twitter
- Facebook
- Pinterest
- Favorite0
26 comments