I have a few stuffed softies I want to make soon but I bought a few toys off Etsy before he was born - lately these crocheted t-shirt nesting bowls have been a hit. I went back to the seller's shop and am loving the pirate eye patches and superhero masks she has listed! They are so cheap! All from recycled tshirts: http://www.etsy.com/shop/yourmomdesigns?ref=seller_info
Do you have any Etsy hits or homemade toys??