Have you ever been giving a gift from your SO that you didn't like? If so how did you react? Did you keep it, return it or exchange it?

I received jewelry this weekend for our two years which is tomorrow. DH thinks he is buying really nice jewelry (he called it "fancy") when it is really cheaply made, I'm not sure it's even gold plated. He bought it at JCP's jewelry department & even bought the 3 year warranty for it. Last year for Christmas he bought me tiny diamond earrings from some random website that were white colored stones. Both times I smiled, acted excited and wear the jewelry often because I appreciate the kind gesture & I would hate to poo on his parade.