OK - this is silly but I need advice on which card to order off Etsy for our 2 year anniversary coming up.

There is a shop that makes custom hand cut cards. My husband and I do this thing where we say "I love your more than....insert your absolute favorite thing". Coke is absolutely one of my favorite things!!! So she has a card that saids "I love you more than diet coke" to make it Coke it'll be $12!!!! With S+H it'll be almost $20 for the card.

OR.

There's another seller that sells a hand cut card with the NYC landscape, your last names, wedding date for $6.
That's half the price.

So should I be crazy and spend $20 on a card? Or just get the cheaper one?
We do save all our cards.