I bought DH a soft side cooler lunch bag two years ago and he has used it pretty much M-F since I gave it to him. it's pretty thrashed as he has been in paramedic and fire schools in that time frame, as well as being an EMT. it gets used a lot and needs to keep food cool.

I want to replace it for him for Christmas and I'm looking for suggestions. I have a PackIt Cooler for when I pump and while I like the idea, it doesn't close well enough for me to get it for DH's lunch. Any suggestions?

ETA: this is what I gave DH: a mini cooper lunch bag! so the strap is very helpful, but it doesn't need to be tall and skinny.