Hellobee Boards

We loved Couples Swept Away in Negril, Jamaica, it was adults only, clean, great food, and plenty of things to do off resort (but also a ton of stuff to do on!)

For a reasonably priced all-inclusive I think your best bet will be Mexico (Cancun/Riviera Maya/Playa del Carmen). Not sure about stuff off-site to do. Maybe see the Mayan ruins?

A few years ago we went to the Bahia Principe (Punta Cana) and stayed in the adults only section. It was beautiful and relaxing, a pretty good price in my opinion, and since the whole resort was so large there was a lot to do (pools, restaurants, etc) but you could also retreat to the adults section for a more quiet experienc.

We did Couples Tower Island in Jamaica and LOVED it.

We stayed at Secrets Maroma Beach last year and it was amazing! So beautiful.

Aruba or Curaçao might be a good choices since it will be Hurricane season and they are below the hurricane belt. I think Curaçao requires a connecting flight, but Yiu can find direct flights to Aruba from many East coast cities. I haven't ever been to Aruba, but we went to neighboring Curaçao on our honeymoon. We stayed at a Hyatt there and chose to have just breakfast included, but it was so huge, we just ate a big brunch everyday and then bought dinner. When we went 4 years ago it was pretty new and very reasonable ($130-150 per night for ocean view with breakfast). Curaçao is an excellent choice of you love snorkeling and/or
Scuba diving. I don't think Aruba's snorkeling is quite as good, but supposedly they have nicer beaches and more resorts than Curacoa. My friend goes to the Hyatt in Aruba every year but I think it's expensive.

@krispi: I second the Valentin Imperial Maya! DH and I actually got engaged there, and we're going back again for what will be (hopefully!) a babymoon/family trip in December. It's such a beautiful resort!