Sorry if this is the wrong spot!

In an effort to get my mind on positive things, I am redecorating my living room. I ordered an item costing 25 plus 10 for shipping. Etsy says that it was delivered yesterday at 2:18 but, when my husband came home, it was nowhere to be seen. I checked the bushes and all over the house. I am anxiously waiting for my mail carrier to show up to ask them if they remember delivering the package. It was sent priority and has a 100 insurance. I am super disappointed to be out of the money and because it was a one of a kind item and was exactly what I was looking for. Plus, I hate that someone stole off my front porch.

So, I am wondering, has anyone had something sent through USPS that had the wrong delivery date? If you have ever had a package stolen, did you make a claim through PayPal or the post office? Did you get reimbursed? Does it cover stolen packages? Am I just out of luck? I understand that the seller is not at fault at all and this is a gray area.

Thank you for making it through all this. I have been scouring the Internet and haven't found much. Advice is appreciated.