Fall is in the air in New York!

I need to buy Charlie some new fall sneakers, and I'm debating between Toms and Converse. We've had Converse in the past so I know they fit well and are cute! But Toms are just so cute and are slip on/slip off..... but I've heard mixed reviews about them staying on little feet.

Have you tried Tiny Toms? Love em or leave em?