I've started getting ready for bed right after putting Wagon Jr. down, which is so nice because after we eat and hang out I can just brush my teeth and jump right into bed. Here's my routine:

Take out contacts
Neutrogena oil-free eye makeup remover (2 cotton pads soaked 4 times total... I wear a lot of waterproof eye makeup!)
Neutrogena Naturals Purifying Facial Cleanser with warm water
Neutrogena Alcohol-Free Toner (1 cotton pad soaked)
Shiseido The Skincare night cream
Put on glasses

Wow, I didn't realize just how loyal I am to Neutrogena! Also, I'm planning on switching back to Borghese (by Costco) once the pricey Shiseido runs out... honestly, the cheaper Borghese works just as well, I think.