Mine was surprising to me. I was thinking, "That's my baby?" I didn't recognize her. I don't know why I thought I would, as I'd never seen her before. But for some reason I just assumed I'd know what she looked like, and I didn't.
My second thought was oh my goodness she's sooooo beautiful, I'm so in love, and she looks like a Rose. (I was worried her name wouldn't fit but it does.) But it took me a second to get to this much more normal reaction.
How did you react when you saw your baby for the first time?