It's a tie between S'mores and Cherry Garcia. What about yours?
-
My favorite is Karamel Sutra!!
-
It was this but they discontinued it...sad.
-
Coffee Heath bar crunch, cherry Garcia, cookie dough!
-
How can you choose just one?! Yum!
-
@swedishfish: I never knew about that one! Yum!
-
@HLK208: I've never tried s'more...what's the ice cream flavor? And then marshmallow, graham cracker and chocolate or fudge? I need to go try some!
@autumnlove: coffee Heath bar crunch is my favorite too
-
Coffee heath or half baked!
-
Americone Dream!
-
Cherry Garcia
-
CG, hands down.
-
I've never ever tasted Ben and Jerry's ice cream.
-
@swedishfish: You've seen that they're bringing back "Core" flavors again, right? http://www.benjerry.com/flavors/cores
-
@sandy: yep! It's a chocolate ice cream with graham cracker, marshmallow and chocolate chunks swirled together. Other brands version of s'mores are terrible!
@Stacy: I can't help but think of a Friends episode when Joey is talking to Ross..."What are you talking about? One woman? That's like saying there's only one flavor of ice cream for you. Let me tell you something - there's lots of flavors out there. There's Rocky Road, and Cookie Dough, and Bing - Cherry-vanilla" haha!
-
This is like asking me to choose my favorite child, haha!
My all-time is probably Heath Bar Crunch. Peanut Butter Cup is another fave.
@swedishfish: I just tried a new core one, it's peanut butter and chocolate ice cream with a peanut butter chocolate fudge core (with mini peanut cups too!). And they made one that's chocolate raspberry which sounds good too!
-
@mossyslane: oh yes....but I'm trying to forget that they're back for my waistline's sake.
@Trailmix: mmmmm, that sounds good!
-
Chubby hubby. I ate an entire pint of it the day of my miscarriage. It was the best therapy in the world. I also love Americone dream and not just because I love all things Stephen Colbert.
-
Cherry Garcia!
-
Chubby Hubby! Also love Phish Food and Half Baked and Everything But the...
-
@swedishfish: Okay, I figured you had, but just had to check!
-
@autumnlove: @erinpye: coffee Heath lovers unite!!
-
Phish food!
-
Phish Food and Half Baked! They discontinued it, but my other favorite was Magic Brownies.
-
I've never had Ben & Jerry's...which saddens me more than it probably should. I've definitely drooled over the Flavour Graveyard on their site, though!
-
Chubby Hubby, Half Baked or Cinnamon Buns. Ugh, gun to head if I had to say just one, I guess...no I can't. They're all so good!!!
-
@babyjmama: me,me! Take me with you! health lover over here!!! Let's raid the ice cream aisle PLEASE.
-
They have a Blueberry Vanilla Graham frozen Greek yogurt that I love, and Americone Dream.
I want to try Boston Cream Pie, Red Velvet Cake, and Chocolate Therapy sounds right up my alley (chocolate ice cream with chocolate cookies and swirls of chocolate pudding).
-
@lovehoneybee: I spent a minute today debating on Red Velvet! The blueberry graham sounds delightful. I haven't tried any of the Greek yogurt kind because I don't want to be disappointed!
-
@HLK208: I didn't like the Banana Peanut Butter one as much, but I love the Blueberry one. I think it tastes a lot like blueberry cheesecake!
-
Half baked, Cinnamon Buns, and 7 Layer Coconut Bar (which I think is now discontinued).
-
Coffee Heath Bar
-
Oh man I could never pick just one...Chocolate Therapy, Karamel Sutra, Coffee Toffee Heath, Half Baked...and they had a seasonal Pumpkin Cheesecake one that was amazing! I really want to try the Salted Caramel core one but it has gluten.
@NCSUchick27: Magic Brownies was so good!! I don't understand why they discontinue some of the best flavors!
-
@lovehoneybee: I like this!
-
No one said chunky monkey???
-
@CupQuakeWalk: Ohh I haven't tried that one yet!
-
Ok, so I have something to admit:
Last night, I went to the store and the half-baked frozen yogurt was on sale (I think it's being discontinued?). I got it as a special treat. I gotta say, though, that I was kinda disappointed. I mean, don't get me wrong--I still ate the whole thing--but I was expecting something way better. Was it because it was the frozen yogurt??
I'm so bummed, lol.
-
@CupQuakeWalk: consider it a date, my ice cream loving friend!!
-
@lovehoneybee: you must!
-
Creme brûlée!!
-
This thread makes me seriously depressed that I can't have dairy products.
I think I will go sulk over a pint of chocolate coconut milk ice cream... the next best thing
I think I will go sulk over a pint of chocolate coconut milk ice cream... the next best thing Subscribe to our newsletter
- Google Plus
- Stumbleupon
- Twitter
- Facebook
- Pinterest
- Favorite0
50 comments