My 8 year old sister tragically lost her special puppy a few months ago, and she has been saving her money for a new puppy... this amazing little girl has saved nearly $400 in about 4 months! She is incredible!

She found a new puppy and they're picking her up next weekend! She is SO excited, though still mourning the loss of her angel puppy.

Anyway... I'm going to buy her this puppy memorial tag, but I also want to give her a pet ID tag for her new dog - I know she'll love it!

Can't decide which one to get though!
Help me decide

(oh the first pic is the memorial ID!)