OK, I'm determined to make this decision now.

1) KidKraft Grand Gourmet Corner Kitchen.

http://www.toysrus.com/product/index.jsp?productId=3807222&skuid=6713841

Pros: More space to play, currently on sale at TRU
Cons: Eh, it's pink, but I could theoretically paint it?

2) KidKraft Suite Elite Kids Imaginative Pretend Play Wood Kitchen

http://www.ebay.com/itm/KidKraft-Suite-Elite-Kids-Imaginative-Pretend-Play-Wood-Kitchen-53216-/231065953947?pt=Pretend_Play_Preschool_US&hash=item35cc9aa69b

Pros: Wouldn't feel the urge to paint it
Cons: Smaller, but our apartment really isn't super big, like, at all

I'm lazy and would probably have the TRU one shipped, so the price would be the same.