I usually eat the black side first and save the white side for the end. Yum, I want a black and white cookie now.
-
Ahhhh B&W cookies are my fave! We gave them out in welcome bags for our wedding. I voted black first but really I'd eat them in any order
-
I eat them from the middle, lol. I make sure to equally eat from both chocolate and vanilla side. Man, I miss black and whites. The ones with real soft frosting, not just that hardened frosting-like stuff.
-
nom nom nom. I miss these. You can't get these often in Texas and if you do, they aren't as good as NY ones.
-
Down the middle! I made them this weekend...yummm
-
@travellingbee: I'll send you one!
do you want some real bagels too?@LovelyPlum: you made them? Fancy! I'd probably eat them all if I made some.
-
Umm never heard of these!! Lol
-
Bite down the middle, like the picture! Looks so good...
-
@swedishfish: um... Yeah! I'm actually headed up to NYC in a couple weeks and I'll eat the heck outta pizza, bagels, b/w cookies, hard rolls.... Oh yumminess!
-
White! The black side is too overpowering.
-
I love black and white cookies! I always eat the white first.
-
@travellingbee: I just asked DH if he had seen these cookies since we have been in TX!!! He said no as well
This made me miss these glorious cookies....
-
My first bite is usually a little bit of both, but I always save the white for last. I feel like we're in an episode of Seinfeld - "look to the cookie!"
-
Black!
-
Never had one.
-
@Bao: I'm with you. I've never heard of them either!
-
Mmm!!!! I love black and white cookies!!
I save the chocolate for last since it's the best side!
-
Where does everyone get them other than NY and Chicago?!
-
I've heard of them (unwrapped episode I think) but I've never had one!
-
I have never heard of those!
-
Middle. We have a great deli (Chompies, it was on Man vs. Food) here that makes them (considering we're in AZ, not NY)
-
@Bao: me either!!
-
Down the middle, like the picture
-
Down the middle, too!
-
Never had one!
-
@loopedd: We gave them out at our wedding too!!
-
@LindsayInNY: We really are twins in a lot of ways!!
-
I've never heard of these cookies.
-
I've never had one of these, only seen them in delis, and now I'm curious!
-
@swedishfish: I've never tried one. They look so elegant. I imagine they are just sugar cookies with frosting. How do they taste?
-
Wow I'm surprised at how many people have never had/heard of b&w cookies!
I guess I just take them for granted since I grew up with them and you can find them virtually everywhere in NY. But taste/quality certainly runs the gamut depending on where you get them.
-
right down the middle for me!
-
@Bao: me either!
-
@Mrs. Lemon-Lime: a good one is different than a sugar cookie. It's more cake like. Yum! I feel like I should send one to everyone who's never tried one. My local bakery makes awesome ones.
-
I have never had one!
-
I've only had them in NYC since you don't find them often in the south. I eat them down the middle.
do you want some real bagels too?
This made me miss these glorious cookies....
Reply
Subscribe to our newsletter
- Google Plus
- Stumbleupon
- Twitter
- Facebook
- Pinterest
- Favorite0
35 comments