Hellobee Boards

Login/Register

Yay or Nay: Happiest Baby on the Block?

  1. Maysprout

    grapefruit / 4800 posts

    Yay. We watched the DVD and it worked great.

  2. JoyfulKiwi

    nectarine / 2667 posts

    I read the book and liked it. I liked the idea/reasoning behind the 4th trimester. We didn't do a whole lot with it after our son was born, because he wasn't a very fussy baby. We used swaddle sacks, jiggling, and side-lying (he still loves side-lying and will knock right out when we do it!). We didn't ever use a white noise machine, but did some loud shushing & it seemed to calm him down.

  3. HLK208

    pineapple / 12234 posts

    Yay! It was super helpful for us.

  4. autumn865

    persimmon / 1147 posts

    Interesting enough but it felt like a lot of "fluff" to make it a whole book. I could have skimmed it and read what the "5s's" were and could have gotten the same out of it.

  5. MrsF

    honeydew / 7283 posts

    I'd go for the DVD (no time to read a book with a newborn). We had a colicky baby who was very difficult to soothe. While it's not magic, it's empowering to feel like you've got some tools to use.

  6. PinkElephant

    grapefruit / 4584 posts

    It's worth watching once, but you don't need to own it.

  7. skibobrown

    pomegranate / 3388 posts

    Yay! Our baby was pretty laid back overall, but notoriously difficult to get to sleep. The 5 Ss worked great for getting her to go down.

  8. lemondrop

    bananas / 9118 posts

    Yay! Worked for us You can find it for cheap in most used book stores pretty easily. The book does repeat itself a lot, it could state everything once and be 50% shorter. Haven't seen the movie, but I've heard it's a great shortcut.

  9. erinpye

    pomegranate / 3706 posts

    YAY! We had an extremely colicky baby for 6 months--it worked! As did babywearing.

  10. ValentineMommy

    pomelo / 5791 posts

    Big YAY! We watched the DVD and I skimmed the book. Helped tremendously.

  11. T.H.O.U.

    wonderful clementine / 24134 posts

    Yes - We read the book. I wouldn't say it was a miracle but my husband really was able to swaddle, sway, and shoosh, and she would go down almost every time for him.

  12. PurpleUnicorn

    persimmon / 1035 posts

    yay! i can't say it was sooo useful in specifically teaching me the 5 Ss, but rather reading that book changed my perspective and parenting approach. For example, when L was born, i held beliefs such as you can "spoil" a baby by picking them up too much, so it's better to try to get them to sleep on their own (as in from day one). now i am big believer and practicer in babywearing.

  13. BlueWolverine

    pear / 1510 posts

    Yay! The DVD is much better than the book - you have to see it in action to understand just how to do it. When LO was very tiny, the shushing in her ear almost always calmed her. Try all 5 S's and see what works. The side thing never did much for her. Overall, though, I highly recommend.

  14. Mrs. High Heels

    blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts

    I read the book and watched the DVD. Nay to the book, but YAY to the DVD!

  15. Mrs. Confetti

    blogger / pomegranate / 3491 posts

    The white noise CD that comes with the book/dvd is outstanding - we play the 6th track on a loop for all of LO's naps and nights. We definitely used the 5 S's when C was a newborn. We actually got to meet Dr Karp - LO was his swaddling demo baby on TV when he was 9 weeks. He "sssh"'s SO loudly - it was unbelievable.

  16. Katrocap

    persimmon / 1230 posts

    Didn't know there was a DVD, but the book was very helpful when LO was 6 weeks to 3 months. We did the 4 S's, because my DS was interested in sucking. It rarely put him to sleep but often calmed him down when he was colicky.

  17. Mrs. Stroller

    blogger / nectarine / 2010 posts

    M started to STTN at 3 weeks so I give it a HUGE Yay! I liked the DVD, DH read the book. We also used moms on call.

Reply

You must login / Register to post

© copyright 2011-2014 Hellobee