Following on from the breastfeeding thread -- I had an elective C for many reasons and got a lot of flack for it from all over (MIL, sister, nurses, etc). It was pretty much explicitly stated that unless I had 'a good reason', I should try NVD.
What do you think?
*I mean an elective C after 38/39 weeks
184 votes
coconut / 8475 posts
Nope. And I see a bigger difference between breastfeeding and c-sections too, fwiw
GOLD / wonderful apricot / 22646 posts
Nope, again. A very personal and individual decision.
And if anything, don't most people say that c-section recovery is harder? I don't think c-section mamas should get any flack from anyone whether by choice or circumstance.
pomegranate / 3779 posts
Again, not my body, so I don't have any say. If the woman and her OB are ok with it, then why not?
apricot / 347 posts
@CupQuakeWalk: Oh, I didn't mean to compare them, oh dear. I was just thinking about people in that thread talking about FFs getting flack and I was thinking about C-sectioners getting it too, that was my thought process. Hope it doesn't offend anybody!
grapefruit / 4278 posts
So I'll take some heat, but I voted yes... with a caveat. I think there are particular circumstances where electing to have a c-section is appropriate. But barring any medical conditions or complications I think that a woman should try to have a vaginal delivery. I agree with others that I wouldn't tell someone what to do, but will side-eye someone who elects to have a section out of convenience.
wonderful pomelo / 30692 posts
I'm basically going to quote @hilsy85: from the last thread:
I PERSONALLY can't imagine a situation in which I wouldn't at least try to breastfeed deliver vaginally. And if it didn't work, it didn't work.
But I mean, I think it's hard for me to say what another woman should do with her boobs vagina. I think as long as she feeds her baby in some way doesn't try to force the baby to stay in the womb forever, then it's all good.
/endquote (strikethrough and added words)
wonderful cherry / 21504 posts
I don't see them as the same thing (breastfeeding vs c-section), and I can't really think of many reasons why someone would choose a c-section (aka surgery) for their first without a medical reason, but I don't see why *I* should have a say in the matter.
I understand and support the discouragement of early elective c-sections, which you already said you aren't talking about. So, no I guess I don't think you should have to try for a vaginal birth. I just don't really know why you wouldn't-- but you (general you and personal you) don't have to explain your reasons to me.
GOLD / coconut / 8266 posts
@mrsjyw: @stine_ciro: agreed.
Some people have medical reasons for having a c-section that they don't feel like broadcasting to the world. Baby's safely delivered? Mama's ok? Good, that's all that matters.
GOLD / pomegranate / 3688 posts
@Adira: My DD regularly tries to climb back into my stomach... but I'm not forcing her!!! 
GOLD / pomelo / 5737 posts
Nope, although I can't personally imagine wanting a c section because I always read about how hard the recovery is. Still Im sure there are cases where vaginal deliveries are more difficult too. It's between a mama and her dr!
I hope she doesn't mind my mentioning her but @dandelion comes to mind.
papaya / 10343 posts
I think every mom should do what is best for her, and no one else should express an opinion on that. I've done a bit of research on various child birthing methods and I am personally trying for a med-free vaginal delivery. But my reasons for that are primarily that I think it will make recovery easier on ME. I think a c-section would be harder on ME. I don't think that I've read anything that makes me feel that the risks to a baby are appreciably higher with c-section vs. vaginal birth.
wonderful pomelo / 30692 posts
@googly-eyes: That's a good point. I CAN imagine a situation where I would elect a c-section, depending on how previous births had gone!
I should have said that I personally would want to try to deliver vaginally for a FIRST baby, and then depending on how that went might change my opinion on the next ones!
GOLD / wonderful pea / 17697 posts
I think of this differently, because a c-sec is a major surgery and I could never imagine opting for an elective (but I know there are very valid reasons!) But again, not my body, not my family, not my place to judge.
kiwi / 661 posts
Can you define elective C-section? I think in general vaginal delivery is considered safer and would be my option if I could. Certainly if they thought the baby was large, if my hips were narrow, if my mother, sister, aunts and cousins all had c-sections I would keep an open mind about it.
It doesn't really affect me how anyone else delivers their babies, but I did think it was weird when I was nervous about a possible c-section my non-mother friend didn't understand. It is major surgery and not something I would personally jump into without medical reason.
wonderful pear / 26210 posts
The only thing I feel strongly about is that the baby is given full opportunity to stay inside until it reaches full term status, unless there is something like GD at play. After that, I don't really care.
honeydew / 7589 posts
There are lots of cases where it is safer to deliver via c-section than vaginally (multiples, placenta previa, certain types of breech).
I will say though, it does bother me when a woman chooses to go with an elective c-section purely out of convenience. It does, just because there is higher risk of complication involved with a c-section and I just can't fathom accepting that risk unless you have an actual reason.
pomegranate / 3565 posts
As a mom who had an elective c section at 39 weeks, I voted no. It wasn't my plan from the start but when I found out how much DS was weighing I knew he was not coming out vaginally. Sure, I could have tried, but for me I think a c section was the safest and best choice for both of us. For reference, he was 10 lbs 9 oz.
Just this weekend, my SIL threw a dig at me that I had it easier because I didn't have to push him out. Hmm, you can throw that dig at me next time you push out a 10 1/2 pound baby. From what I remember, her kids were around 7-8 pounds.
grapefruit / 4823 posts
No.
With my second I had an elective (repeat) csection, and had numerous people IRL ask me why I wasnt even going to try to give birth vaginally. I was somewhat taken aback at how many people questioned my decision, as if I hadn't thought about it myself and was just making a casual decision.
coconut / 8234 posts
I feel that if there's no medical/psychological reason why a woman couldn't deliver vaginally, then yes she should at least try. A C-section is major surgery. But I'm only in charge of my body so it doesn't really matter what I think! I'm trying to imagine a situation where I would tell someone, "Well, I really don't think you should have that C-section." No matter what I think, I wouldn't tell another woman what or how to regarding her body and her baby.
pomegranate / 3350 posts
I think there can be many reasons why someone would opt for a C-section and personally I would rather just go ahead and get one if the chances were that I would need on anyway. No sense in going through labor and then end up with a c section if you can avoid it.
grapefruit / 4311 posts
I'm a little more opinionated on this one, but I still wouldn't even give it a sec thought of start to judge someone else's decision, but don't really feel great about elective u/s if there is absolutely no medical reason behind it - it is major surgery after all.
wonderful clementine / 24134 posts
I can totally see why SOME women have really valid reasons for wanting an elective c/s.
However, I do think there are SOME women that, in my opinion, choose to have a more invasive surgical procedure for what I consider less valid reasons. Things like just to schedule a better time, because they are sick of being pregnant, don't want to go through labor, etc.
pomegranate / 3890 posts
Not at all. and I would be offended t if someone questioned my decision to have a c section. I fought like hell to get my son here and I don't care how he was born. Baby #2 will be a planned c section.
pomegranate / 3791 posts
I don't think any reputable doctor is going to do a c-section when there's no medical reason - if someone is having a scheduled c-section I would assume there's a reason for it, and no one is under any obligation to explain their birth decisions to me!
ETA: I don't believe people should be allowed to elect to have a c-section early though. I recall coming across a very old thread where someone was planning on inducing at like 37 weeks a just because it was more convenient for her, and I was pretty appalled. Unless it's medically risky for some reason, you should have to wait until you're in labor and/or the baby is fully developed.
GOLD / pineapple / 12662 posts
As an aside, vaginal delivery is just as *major* as a c-section . . . both can be hugely traumatic to a body . . . the risks may be different, but they are--relatively speaking--equal, all things considered!
pomelo / 5791 posts
No, same answer as last post. Not my body, situation or choice.
I technically elected to have a c-section. I have detached retinas and my doctors fears the pushing would re-detach them. So, I was given the choice for either a c-section, or so many drugs that I wouldn't do any pushing anyway and they would remove him by vacuum or forceps or whatever, I agreed to have the c-section and my doctors thought that was the right choice.
coconut / 8234 posts
@MsLipGloss: True, vaginal delivery is still major. Sometimes I wonder if I got lucky not having to push my baby out (even though I was pretty traumatized by my c-section). But I'm still in the minority on this poll, I voted yes.
honeydew / 7589 posts
@wonderstruck: Unfortunately that is not at all true. There are actually very few doctors who require c-sections to be medically indicated, most are completely willing to perform an elective c-section.
GOLD / pineapple / 12662 posts
@mrsjazz: My induction was miserable . . . 27 hours of active back labor . . . and to make a long story much shorter, I almost bled out. From my point of view, a section would have been just as tough . . . although shorter and with the possibility of fewer complications/drugs!
| Today | Monthly Record | |
|---|---|---|
| Topics | 0 | 1 |
| Posts | 1 | 1 |
Ask for Help
Make a Suggestion
Frequently Asked Questions
Bee Levels
Acronyms
Most Viewed Posts
Hellobee Gold
Hellobee Recipes
Hellobee Features
Hellobee Contests
Baby-led Weaning
Bento Boxes
Breastfeeding
Newborn Essentials
Parties
Postpartum Care Essentials
Sensory Play Activities
Sleep Training
Starting Solids Gear
Transitioning to Toddler Bed
All Series
Who We Are
About the Bloggers
About the Hostesses
Contributing Bloggers
Apply to Blog
Apply to Hostess
Submit a Guest Blog
Hellobee Buttons
How We Make Money
Community Policies
- Google Plus
- Stumbleupon
- Twitter
- Facebook
- Pinterest
- Favorite0
127 comments