Yes, I realize I give people advice on this on a daily basis, but it's different when it's your kid!

We attempted around 28 months and it was actually going really well, but Dh caved and gave it back to her one night. Now it's a nightmare. She has gotten exponentially more attached to it over the past 6 months. She has really outsmarted us.

She is not interested in the paci fairy, we talked about going to build a bear:nope! She says she doesn't want to put her paci in there. I told her if she used it too much it would break, and she used to say if it broke she would throw it away, but now she says she will cry and she will never go to sleep. It's her lovey. She is wild and it's the only thing that calms her down. I just feel so sad taking away her lovey but it's gotta go. I tried getting her attached to other things but it just doesn't happen. She's way too smart and fully aware that we could just go buy more at the store. Also baby brother uses one and she says she'll just take one of his...