I'm going crazy, I know, but I can't pick between these dolls. I'm not even into realistic dolls, I like stuffed animals and ragdolls! But DD really liked the vinyl doll at the doctor's office.

I've actually already bought her a doll, but canceled it after reading the rave reviews on the soft bodied dolls (the one I got was an anatomically correct all vinyl one).

DD is 18 months. Here are my choices:

Doll 1:
more expensive
removable clothes
cuter face (?)

Doll 2:
almost $10 cheaper (!)
can't remove the clothes (but can be easily dressed over, if I buy an additional outfit or make my own)
has a pacifier
expression fits pacifier