Hellobee Boards

Login/Register

Baby shower for baby #2?

  • poll: Did you have a Baby Shower for baby #2?
    Yes : (10 votes)
    10 %
    No : (62 votes)
    60 %
    Yes, 2nd baby was opposite sex of #1 baby : (13 votes)
    13 %
    No, same sex so I had everything : (18 votes)
    17 %
  1. meredithNYC

    pomegranate / 3314 posts

    @looch: Ohhhhh... then yeah, I wouldn't refuse. BUT, I am the type who would bitch about it to my husband and also kind of resent going - which might be worse!

  2. erinbaderin

    pomelo / 5573 posts

    I I don't really get the "all babies should be celebrated" thing. I mean, I agree that all babies should be celebrated by their family. But I don't really see how a baby shower (or a sprinkle, or whatever) is celebrating the baby - it seems like it's celebrating the mom. It's like throwing a birthday party for somebody who isn't there. I always bring a little gift when invited to go and meet a new baby, regardless of how many other babies there in the family, but I would definitely resent being invited to a second-baby shower. Lucky for me, it's not a thing in my group of friends.

  3. LadyPantaloons

    grape / 80 posts

    DS (opposite sex from first) is due in Dec and I think my sister is planning a "sip and see" tea in January (very uncommon to have showers before the baby is born in my area). I imagine I and the baby will get some gifts. I'm hoping for diapers, wipes, and either meals or gift cards for curb-side pick-up meals.

  4. AggieDaze

    apricot / 448 posts

    One of my best friends threw a sprinkle for our same sex LO2. She asked ahead of time, and I was fine with it as long as there was a note on the invitations that made it clear that I did not want presents. She put something like "Your company is present enough. No gifts please."

    Honestly, it was wonderful and I'm so glad that she did it. It was a smaller group than my first LO's showers and we were really able to just sit around and catch up (which is tough to do typically with a toddler).

  5. AggieDaze

    apricot / 448 posts

    I think its also weird that a lot of responses on this board equate a shower or sprinkle with gifts.

    I like the idea of a get together to celebrate subsequent children, but would want to ensure no one felt obligated to bring a gift.

  6. mauxie

    persimmon / 1043 posts

    I had a different gender 2nd and did not have a shower.

    A friend of mine brought it up and offered to put something together for me, but I just said "ohh I don't really need anything" and left it at that. I'm sure if I was more interested, she would've been happy to host.

    Personally I felt a shower wasn't needed since my two are relatively close in age and I already have all the gear. Plus, I figured people who were going to gift us diapers or clothes would do so regardless. So for those friends we had them come over to meet the baby and a quick dinner or dessert. It was nice!

  7. blackbird

    wonderful grape / 20453 posts

    I did not, but E and T are 25 months apart. Some of my friends did take me to lunch and gifted me some boy things, though

  8. Mrs. Lemon-Lime

    wonderful pea / 17279 posts

    @AggieDaze: hmm, I don't see how a shower or sprinkle is not a gift giving activity since a big component of a baby shower is showering the mom to be with gifts and 9/10 watching her open them. A sprinkle is a new/ more polite term for a second baby's shower- smaller scale in number of people and scope of gifts. But both events are focused on gifts/ prepping mom with stuff for the baby.

    I would need "no gifts" spelled out very clearly on a shower or sprinkle invite for me to understand a gift was not necessary.

  9. mauxie

    persimmon / 1043 posts

    @AggieDaze: I think any time the words "shower" or "sprinkle" are involved, people bring gifts. In my circle, even when you write "no gifts, please" people still bring gifts! It'd be different though if it was worded more as just a get-together before baby comes.

  10. AggieDaze

    apricot / 448 posts

    @Mrs. Lemon-Lime and @Mauxie: I guess what I meant earlier is that I think its kinda shitty that some people assume that someone who is having a party of some kind for their second LO is only out for presents (but no one specifically said that on this board though I have heard it before). But, I do agree that showers and sprinkles unfortunately tend to have that connotation.

    I'm probably a tad defensive about it as I didn't feel like I could say "no" to the person who asked to throw something, but also didn't want anyone to think it was in bad taste or because I wanted presents.

    Ultimately, I tried to avoid that connotation by asking the person throwing the "sprinkle" to add very clear language on the invitation. I also personally mentioned that I didn't want any gifts (the number of people invited was less than 8). There was no opening of gifts at my "sprinkle," no gift table, no gifts mentioned period.

  11. Mamasig

    pomegranate / 3565 posts

    Just wanted to add that a lot of it may be cultural. My family is from Central America, and my mom thinks that every baby should get a shower. I told her it wasn't needed as my kids are both boys and only 20 months apart in age.

    I've been to sprinkles and am totally fine with that. It was mostly just personalized gifts anyway.

    I've also had to go to a SIL's shower (not sprinkle) for her 4th kid. She registered and everything. I felt that was pretty excessive. But once again, maybe cultural?

  12. MaisyMay

    GOLD / cantaloupe / 6703 posts

    I have been at my company since just before LO1 turned 1. Now that LO2 is due in the spring, several people have asked if they can do a work shower. I mentioned it was really unnecessary, but even my boss is really excited, so I will be having a work shower.
    I am excited for a chance to have some social time worth my coworkers after the busy winter we are going to have, but will also mention that gifts are unnecessary. My coworkers want a chance to celebrate since many are either well done with having kids or have no plans soon.

  13. jh524

    pear / 1632 posts

    Lots of great perspectives here! I know a lot of people who love giving gifts,myself included, but only when the budget allows otherwise it becomes a strain. Too bad we couldn't feel great celebrating each baby and just state gifts optional lol. Or maybe making the party a gender reveal or diaper party or something. Many people want to share in the joy but I could see if a second mom had a huge gift registry and the whole nine how that could look gift grabby.

  14. dolphin

    pomegranate / 3768 posts

    My close friends threw me a surprise sprinkle. I was really touched!

Reply

You must login / Register to post

© copyright 2011-2014 Hellobee