With my first, I didn't babywear much since I was gifted a really awful carrier at my baby shower and I assumed they all felt the same way. It was an infantino and I gave it away. Since he was my first, I held him all the time and it really wasn't a problem.

With my second, the Beco Gemini saved my life! E loved it and I could still be hands-on with B. The strap broke about 5 months in and their customer service stunk. They had me take a picture of my receipt, the product, send it in (I paid for shipping) and they said there was nothing they could do. The straps changed on the 2013 model so I bought it and we did use the carrier a lot until E was 13-14 months. Then I read that the seat isn't big enough to support toddlers hips.

So, now that I'm having another, I'll need a great carrier. We bought the ergo which I tried out with E and although it looks like it supports her better, it hurts my back more than the Beco.

I also bought a K'tan which I'm hoping will help with the early days with baby #3.

What carriers worked for you? How did you decide on one?