pomegranate / 3809 posts
@Ree723: wow, I'm sorry. I would definitely try to negotiate with the doctors office. It's ridiculous how much they charge individuals. They can't even get away with charging the insurance company that much, their negotiated rate is SO much lower! I would try to find out what a "reasonable" negotiated rate is and see if they can charge you that. (This isn't for baby vaccs, but for example, for an office procedure, my doctor would charge $300 on the bill, but then with insurance, they discount it $180! So the doc only ends up getting $120 for it!) If that doesn't work, another trick I read is to set up a payment plan (should be 0%), then after your first bill comes, call them up and ask if they will offer a discount if you pay in full right then. Good luck!
grapefruit / 4819 posts
Thanks for all the responses everyone! It's great to hear some different perspectives on this, which is also helping to temper some of my anger
I can't respond to everyone individually now as it's gone onto the second page but just a couple of points. @sleepymonkey: Actually, our tax rates are similar, or slightly lower than those in the US when you factor in the insurance costs (based on my experience). DH's take home pay in the UK now is 71% of his salary, and he makes a pretty nice wage; in Australia, he was making a salary that put us in the highest tax bracket, and including the 9% of his pay check that was taken out for student loans, he was still bringing home nearly 60% of his salary (so a tax rate of 31-32%). Our sales tax is significantly higher (I think around 17.5%) but since it's already been included in the price on the price tag, you don't really notice it.
@espion: I recently read an article in Time talking about the disparity in hospital costs and the inflation of costs without apparent justification for the increase - things like a single Motrin tablet were being charged at a rate of $70 per pill. That is insanity. And I know that money doesn't go into the pocket of providers, which is what makes it even more ridiculous.
@sunny: Yes, the bill was itemised and the cost of the administration of the vaccines was a separate charge, so the prices I listed were just for the actual vaccine. I'm actually ok with the charges for the nurse's work because she did the most work that day, but sadly, I know she's probably bringing home the smallest pay check.
@PurplePumps: Ooh, I wish I had known that about the payment plan! I have a call in to the doctor, who will apparently be calling back tomorrow, to see if we can't knock down some of the office charges. He's usually been really good about that, but now that he's in with this network, I'm not sure how much flexibility he has with that anymore.
Thanks to all those who commiserated - I was absolutely fuming earlier and a bit of sympathy, and perspective, helped calm me down a bit
hostess / wonderful apple seed / 16729 posts
@Mrs. Pen: Thank you. Glad I explained it well. Yeah, I'm hoping all the research won't be lost, either.
@sunny: Thank you. Exactly.
@SleepyMonkey: Thank you for those numbers! That's new to me, and it definitely makes sense. The assays that I run can run into the $5-10K for each test. Anything research related can be so expensive. Also, interesting that 1-2% drugs make it to market. I knew the number was low but 1-2% is tiny. Wow! Having a number like that is so eye opening. Haha! That's coming from me. Welcome to reality. Haha. I know this is part of my job and being in science, studies sometimes don't work as you had hoped or planned. We just have to keep reminding ourselves what our goal is and that find a cure or treatment.
blogger / pear / 1563 posts
I know. It's absolutely horrible!! We had that kind of bill once, and after that we went to the public health clinic. This was when we had absolutely awful health insurance. And OF COURSE they tell you they don't know how much it will cost, which is so entirely corrupt and gross to me.
pineapple / 12566 posts
@SleepyMonkey: just for perspective, I live in Austria, which has a mixed system. I'm self employed and 30% of my income goes to the social healthcare and 20ish% to income taxes. So yeah, I pay A TON more in taxes than I ever did in the US.
grapefruit / 4006 posts
@Ree723: this is interesting! i talk to people in the UK pretty frequently for work and they always complain about how high the taxes are so much higher there than the US (60% v. 35% for similar tax brackets). however, i could have a biased sample set because the people i talk to are mostly quite wealthy.
@lamariniere: ouch! this is the impression that i had for most of developed Europe.
i swear i didn't pull this tax info out of thin air! i am guessing it varies from person to person.
grapefruit / 4819 posts
@SleepyMonkey: Interesting article, thanks for sharing!! It's so hard to find data that clearly lays it out,but this one did a pretty good job. I know in England and Australia, the tax rates are proportional to your income. Right now in the UK, your salary up to £32,000 (which is a pretty decent salary) is taxed at 20%. Everything you make beyond that is taxed at 40%, so there is definitely a tipping point where your taxes start to become pretty high, but that tends to come once you're getting into more serious money. Most people, with comfortable salaries, in good jobs, with a good standard of living, aren't going to come anywhere near paying 40% income tax. And if they do, they're making bucket loads of money and need to stop whinging
Thanks for the info, I find this fascinating!
wonderful pear / 26210 posts
@Ree723: I think you edited your original post, because it did come across as though you had written that anyone that would live in a place without socialized medicine was a complete moron. I don't think it's that easy for a lot of people to move around the world, a lot of places have pretty strict visa requirements.
Fact of the matter is, though, that every system has its imperfections and nothing is free, anywhere. Just because you aren't personally paying a bill doesn't mean it is free. I also feel as though the doctor was correct to bill you as they did. You don't have insurance beyond travel insurance, I am guessing since you are here temporarily you aren't paying taxes, so what should have been the correct protocol for the doctor to follow?
grapefruit / 4819 posts
@looch: Oh wow, that was certainly not my intent at all to suggest that anyone living in a country without universal healthcare was a moron. I most certainly understand that it's not that easy for people to move countries and fully appreciate that I am in a fortunate position where I am able to do so. I haven't edited my original post but I am truly sorry if my message came across that way. As for taxes, no I'm not paying taxes in the US (although I have in the past) but I also didn't expect it to be free. I was happy to pay for the services, I'm just outraged over the cost of the actual vaccines. Those prices are absolutely ludicrous. But like I said, I don't object to paying in general because of course I wouldn't expect it to be free.
bananas / 9899 posts
That price actually doesn't seem that astronomically high to me at all.
I live in Canada and I had to pay over $900 out of pocket for a medication I needed at the beginning of my pregnancy, not covered by OHIP.
Keep in mind that those vaccines still cost that much, and we all still pay for them "out of pocket", we just pay for it in smaller instalments over our entire lifetime. Medical care is never actually free. Infact, we waste so much money in our system for care that often is sub-par. That's the trouble when the government runs things, everything is redundant and overly expensive. I don't think Canada's system is exactly perfect either.
pomelo / 5298 posts
@Ree723: And this makes exactly my point. So many people (myself included) are blissfully unaware of the costs because we either pay nothing or small copays without knowledge of the real money flowing between the insurance companies, doctors, facilities, pharma companies, employers, government, etc.
Again, generally speaking I think most people are not highly knowledgeable about the components and related costs. It's when you are put in the position of having to pay the high costs with no insurance or a high deductible healthplan that you become more aware.
Most of us wouldn't buy a car right off the lot without negotiating or researching, but yet we walk into a doctor office frequently unarmed with information regarding cost. Healthcare consumers are often not "smart" consumers.
wonderful pear / 26210 posts
@Ree723: I thought I read something along the lines of you not wanting to ever live in a place that didn't have socialized medicine. Maybe I misread, if I did, I apologize.
eta: found it, in one of your replies:
@loveisstrange: Yes. I cannot wait to get over to the UK. Healthcare was the single biggest issue that pushed us to living in the UK over the US. I would never willingly choose to live in a country without universal healthcare again. I loved the universal healthcare system in the UK and Australia- beats the US system any day.
---------------------
To compare apples to apples, do you know how much those vaccines cost in the UK or Australia? I am not talking about your out of pocket, but I can not imagine that they are that much less.
grapefruit / 4819 posts
@looch: I just looked it up yesterday actually. Prevenar 13 is around £46, which is about $79, but the NHS is actually using a different vaccine for two years, Pneumax or something like that, to test its effectiveness - it's produced by a French company I think, and it costs £8 per dose. Pfizer says it's not as effective, but who knows? I do agree though, there are absolutely positives and negatives to every health system out there - none of them are perfect.
ETA: Ahh, that wasn't meant to be directed towards anyone else, or imply that anyone who chose otherwise was a big dummy. That is my personal preference and what is important to DH and I. Everyone has different priorities and for us, universal healthcare was a top priority.
pineapple / 12793 posts
@looch: In Canada the total cost of all childhood vaccinations is $856.03. The four month vaccinations are $215.
wonderful pear / 26210 posts
@Ree723: @oliviaoblivia: thanks for the info, i find it better to discuss there things using direct comparisons. Do I wish it were less in the US, yes. But the infrastructure is totally different. It isn't fair to compare the UK to the US.
My son was born abroad, in a country where the government mandates everyone carry insurance. The providing companies are able to offer coverage levels for all incomes. I am fine with that model, but universal healthcare a la NHS? No thank you. It takes all kinds to make the world go around, right?
grapefruit / 4235 posts
We just got the bill for L's 12 mo appointment bc DH's hr lady is crap and for some reason our insurance company didn't think he was on our insurance (fun!) prevnar is itemized at $185 on the bill. That's the "rack" rate, though, not what the insurer would pay for it.
If your insurance won't pay for it, I would see if the dr would take, like, $400 in cash. It's more than he would get from the insurance company.
| Today | Monthly Record | |
|---|---|---|
| Topics | 1 | 1 |
| Posts | -1 | 0 |
Ask for Help
Make a Suggestion
Frequently Asked Questions
Bee Levels
Acronyms
Most Viewed Posts
Hellobee Gold
Hellobee Recipes
Hellobee Features
Hellobee Contests
Baby-led Weaning
Bento Boxes
Breastfeeding
Newborn Essentials
Parties
Postpartum Care Essentials
Sensory Play Activities
Sleep Training
Starting Solids Gear
Transitioning to Toddler Bed
All Series
Who We Are
About the Bloggers
About the Hostesses
Contributing Bloggers
Apply to Blog
Apply to Hostess
Submit a Guest Blog
Hellobee Buttons
How We Make Money
Community Policies
- Google Plus
- Stumbleupon
- Twitter
- Facebook
- Pinterest
- Favorite0
55 comments