My midwife admits that she's not a great guesser (many homebirth midwives can accurately guess an unborn baby's weight within several ounces), but she wouldn't be surprised if I have a 9-pounder. This, after two very average 7 something pound babies for me (with different care providers). So, I guess we'll see!
Did your care provider palpate and guess the weight based on that? How close were they when baby came out?