If it were free and non-invasive, would you choose your LO's sex before getting pregnant? Or would you rather leave it up to chance?
If it were free and non-invasive, would you choose your LO's sex before getting pregnant? Or would you rather leave it up to chance?
127 votes
GOLD / wonderful pomegranate / 28905 posts
I'm honestly really not sure! LO1 is a girl and we are expecting a girl. We may or may not have a third and although I would like the 3rd to be a boy for various reasons I'm not sure I would intentionally choose it...
watermelon / 14206 posts
Not for a first. But I would for a second.
At this point I only want to get pregnant if it were guaranteed to be a girl. Since I can't get that, it ain't gonna happen lol.
GOLD / wonderful pea / 17697 posts
Well, we already have a boy and D would definitely agree to a second LO if we could guarantee a girl so yes, I would.
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21616 posts
Man... This is tough!! I had thought I wanted a girl first and did have some gender disappointment, but now that I have a son I'd be sad to think of all I may have missed out on! I love my little boy.
So I really don't know..
clementine / 933 posts
I voted no. I don't think I could handle the pressure, and I think I'd spend the child's whole life thinking, "What if I'd chosen differently?"
honeydew / 7283 posts
Tough question! I voted no, but if this current pregnancy is a girl (we have a daughter already) I might feel differently about #3!
pomegranate / 3768 posts
I already have a girl so I voted no, I'd leave up to chance for baby 2. But if baby 1 was a boy, I'd choose girl for number 2.
wonderful cherry / 21504 posts
I'd leave it up to chance. Dh would probably choose boy (we already have our daughter) but I wouldn't let him choose.
cantaloupe / 6885 posts
Chance.
I want LO2 to be a girl so dd can have a sister. But I also want LO2 to be a boy so I can have a son (and I know dh would love a boy at some point).
So either way I will be happy
pomegranate / 3565 posts
Yes, assuming I'd have a 3rd child, I choose girl because I have two boys. If I had one of each, I'd leave it to chance.
persimmon / 1177 posts
I didn't vote but I wouldn't for my first, but I would for a second or third child.
pomegranate / 3791 posts
I would totally pick. I'm currently pregnant with boy #2 and am really sad at the thought of never having a daughter, but my husband is not up for #3 unless we could magically guarantee a girl. I can't really explain why it matters to me...I mean, I love my son so fiercely. But I don't know, I have SUCH a good relationship with my mom, and I badly want to experience the other side of a mother-daughter relationship.
persimmon / 1096 posts
Definitely chance! I really firmly believe we are meant for the child or children we have. I wouldn't want to tinker with whatever cosmic forces line up to send those little souls our way
cantaloupe / 6059 posts
I would leave it up to chance! I think that there are so few true surprises in life that it's fun that gender is one of those -- whether you find out at 20 weeks or at delivery!
pomelo / 5258 posts
I think it's best left to chance but if the possibility existed I would choose boy for #2 (we have a girl).
grapefruit / 4213 posts
For the 2nd one, yes. I would choose the opposite of what came first.
apricot / 456 posts
The Billings Method has been shown to be 94% accurate: http://www.bioline.org.br/pdf?rh11010
We used it to predict the sex of our first child. We tried for a girl, and that's what we got! We are going to use it to try for a boy next time.
It would be hard for us to be truly surprised at the gender, since I use natural family planning as my method of birth control--knowing what I do about Billings, I'd probably have a good guess about the gender, even if we DTD everyday. I use a little machine that takes a few urine samples a month to notify me of my fertile days and expected ovulation: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Persona-94031-Contraception-Monitor/dp/B001DUJZUC It has a 94% reliability rate for those who used condoms during "the red days," but we totally abstain during the red days so it's probably better than that. We've been using it for eight years with no accidents.
nectarine / 2220 posts
I'd leave it to chance. I'm the eldest of two girls, and DH has an older sister, and we both think our situation was the BEST combination. We already have a girl, so either way, if we have a second, we'll be mimicking one of our families... no way would that argument ever be settled.
honeydew / 7968 posts
I would leave it up to chance, but as of right now, I voted girl because I have a girl and a boy and am having another boy. If I were to get pregnant again, I'd definitely want another girl.
pineapple / 12234 posts
Chance! Then again, if I had 2 of the same sex, maybe I'd feel differently.
bananas / 9227 posts
I'd want another girl, but even if I could choose it, I'd feel bad about it. I choose chance.
apricot / 456 posts
Because being able to choose the sex doesn't seem as popular, and so far I'm the only person here who has done it, I thought I'd talk a little about our reasons, as well as potential reasons other parents might choose it.
Aside from the Billings Method, which I mentioned above, there is a more high tech way to predict gender called PGD: http://www.cnn.com/2009/HEALTH/12/08/video.wall.gender.baby/index.html?iref=24hours And according to a top scientist who works with it, worldwide there is a 50/50 split between requested boys and girls. I think the fear that, say, boys would be in high demand and not girls if everyone selected their baby's gender is overblown. And let's not forget that if you live in a culture where having a boy is super important to you, there is a good chance you'll just abandon your infant daughter or abort your baby (as in China). Which is the lesser of the two evils, abortion / abandonment, or to give those parents the choice to birth only boys from conception? Though again, this isn't an issue for most countries.
And as the scientist in the article I linked to so succinctly put it, "We've been giving women expanded reproductive choices for 50 years. This is another choice." You have the choice whether to find out if what you're having is a girl or boy via ultrasound. You have the choice whether to go through with a pregnancy at all. I think it's equally important in a free society to let women know that they also have a choice when it comes to the genders of their children (not that any method is 100% accurate of course, but Billings' 94% is pretty darn good). I think it's worth noting by the content of the "what if" of this very thread that most people don't know there is a reliable way to do that yourself.
I know a family with seven children. Six of them are girls. Six! Do you know what the statistical probability of that is? Let me pull out my calculator. It's 1.6%. Extremely unlikely, but hey, it happened to them. They long to have another boy for their son to play with, but so far, no luck. They want what all of us want, when it comes down to it--family balance. I think family balance is actually a lot more important than we sometimes give it credit for, and considering that doing something as simple as timing intercourse correctly could change that, well...why not? I guess I don't quite understand not wanting to know how sex is naturally selected by the timing of intercourse. The equivalent, it seems to me, would be like saying that it's taking too much into your own hands to find out when you ovulate in order to TTC. Sure, you can get pregnant without that information (usually), but there's nothing wrong with taking advantage of our understanding of biological processes that are in place.
For us, we wanted at least one of each gender. We decided to have our eldest child be female for a variety of reasons, but this post is already getting too long so I won't go into them unless someone asks. We'll try for a boy with our second pregnancy. I'm guessing we'll try for a girl again with our third, but we'll have a better idea of that when we get to that point (we eventually want five or six kids).
Today | Monthly Record | |
---|---|---|
Topics | 1 | 0 |
Posts | 0 | 1 |
Ask for Help
Make a Suggestion
Frequently Asked Questions
Bee Levels
Acronyms
Most Viewed Posts
Hellobee Gold
Hellobee Recipes
Hellobee Features
Hellobee Contests
Baby-led Weaning
Bento Boxes
Breastfeeding
Newborn Essentials
Parties
Postpartum Care Essentials
Sensory Play Activities
Sleep Training
Starting Solids Gear
Transitioning to Toddler Bed
All Series
Who We Are
About the Bloggers
About the Hostesses
Contributing Bloggers
Apply to Blog
Apply to Hostess
Submit a Guest Blog
Hellobee Buttons
How We Make Money
Community Policies